i think all HOF's are overrated,there are people in them that you may think don't belong,there are people not in that people think they should be,etc....the bottom line here is,different era's for different people,games have changed in all sports as time goes on,so really how can anyone decide on who belongs or who dosen't.people in todays sports would not make it back in the day,people back in the day would not make it in todays game,its crazy but its all how you look at it.
players get in for all different reasons,300 game winners they say are automatic,but some have never won a world series,....some have 3000 hits but never won a title or a world series,and some don't have 3000 hits but won batting titles and world series but get into the HOF.
it goes on and on in every sport,so this is really a contraversial question,its all about opinions,its who you like,its who comes thru in the clutch,etc,so its really a crap shoot when you look at it.