Will Brady be known as the greatest NFL player ever in 20 years?

[The_Man]

jamarcus rusell

 

[WharfRat+]

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Montana
4. Elway
5. Marino

Top 5 in my lifetime.

 

[texansfan]

ARod easily.

 

[trytrytry]

ARod easily.

or MJ then again maybe tiger....then again maybe we are missing something in this thread.

 

[camy]

I agree with jjgold.

 

[bigtendominator]

I hate John Elway, but nobody has been better. 5 SB, the first 3 with nobody.

Manning will be the greatest ever!

 

[texansfan]

ttt, that was for TB#1.

 

[revetseb]

It's hard to be considered the best ever when you aren't even the greatest QB of your own era.

 

[lapdance]

bradshaw

 

[iamnomad]

Brady is kind of a victim of being on a team that's so effing good. he rarely, if ever, has to bring his team from behind, or do it all himself, for that matter. it's unfair, but he's hardly ever been put in a situation where he must prove himself.

 

[PatPatriot]

Brady is kind of a victim of being on a team that's so effing good. he rarely, if ever, has to bring his team from behind, or do it all himself, for that matter. it's unfair, but he's hardly ever been put in a situation where he must prove himself

New to the game?
Did you happen to watch him last year against the most talented team ever assmbled (according to the media and themselves) SD Chargers, where his number 1 reciver was Reche Caldwell?

 

[Highdaddy]

how many times do i need to say this

Tom Brady is easily better than Peyton Manning

 

[HinesWard86]

I hate John Elway, but nobody has been better. 5 SB, the first 3 with nobody.

Manning will be the greatest ever!

how is john elway easily the best ever? how many of his comeback wins were after he was throwing int after int to put his team down?

look at elway's stats his first 10 years......good but not great. the guy never became great until shanahan stepped in and said look stop throwing fucking int's and be a game manager. remember there is a reason the broncos drafted tommy maddox in 1992, when elway was just 32.

once again, take a look at his stats in his first 10 years. in his first 10 years, he had only ONE more TD than INT. and this was not at a time where there was a lot of clutch and grab either. take a look at the stats of moon, krieg, and esiason in relation to elway.....pretty fucking similar. than look at stats of people like marino and montana and tell me that elway is better than them. ridiculous.

 

[DrunkenHorseplayer]

Give me Manning every time; amazing that regular season stats don't mean anything when Manning puts them up but now that Brady's putting them up they mean everything.

 

[gamerecognizegame]

manning no doubt. i expect manning to win at least 3 more titles as well including this year

 

[Fishhead]

In all due respect, anyone that would put BRADY in the top ten of all-time football players is obviously.......

1. very young
2. doesnt watch a lot of football

 

[Fishhead]

In all due respect, anyone that would put BRADY in the top ten of all-time football players is obviously.......

1. very young
2. doesnt watch a lot of football

I could name 10 offensive lineman better............

 

[WVU]

I could name 10 offensive lineman better............

at what throwing the ball?

 

[TheCrusher]

Brady is kind of a victim of being on a team that's so effing good. he rarely, if ever, has to bring his team from behind, or do it all himself, for that matter. it's unfair, but he's hardly ever been put in a situation where he must prove himself.

Really? What color is the sky on the planet you live on? I'm sure its real pretty there this time of year.

Peyton has directed 16 fourth-quarter comeback wins and 10 fourth-quarter game-winning drives.

Brady has orchestrated 24 game-winning drives to take the lead in the fourth quarter or overtime. Six of his game-winning efforts have come in the postseason, where he has played in 14 games.

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR]

In all due respect, anyone that would put BRADY in the top ten of all-time football players is obviously.......

1. very young
2. doesnt watch a lot of football

If Brady went to Iowa or was from Iowa, it would be a different story..:lol: