Michael Jackson, Billy Joel, Elvis Presley, Elton John; Which Of These Musical Artists Is/Was Most Talented?

Search

Which Of These Artists Was Most Best Overall?

  • Michael Jackson

    Votes: 43 40.2%
  • Billy Joel

    Votes: 20 18.7%
  • Elvis Presley

    Votes: 26 24.3%
  • Elton John

    Votes: 18 16.8%

  • Total voters
    107

Active member
Handicapper
Joined
Jun 18, 2007
Messages
79,471
Tokens
Let`s go back in time with this big hit by Michael

 

Active member
Handicapper
Joined
Jun 18, 2007
Messages
79,471
Tokens
Probably his best

 

Active member
Handicapper
Joined
Jun 18, 2007
Messages
79,471
Tokens
Elton John has a lot of goodies...I`ll come up with a few
 

Active member
Handicapper
Joined
Jun 18, 2007
Messages
79,471
Tokens
One of my favorites

 

Active member
Handicapper
Joined
Jun 18, 2007
Messages
79,471
Tokens
This song is good when it`s blasted....lol

 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,321
Tokens
The fact that Elvis is last is a joke.

As far as entertainer goes.

I would have to put Garth Brooks way up there.
The guy knows how to do a concert.
 

Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2008
Messages
2,660
Tokens
Billy Joel ? Well he knows that it's ME its me me that they're coming to see... Man what is the great Billy Jpel doing in this dump ?
He is a low talent bum.
ever hear of Van Morrison ? Joel couldn't shine his shoes
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,879
Tokens
[ I'm not even a real big fan of the genre of music that Michael Jackson wrote/performed, but after watching the just-released documentary below, and the documentary 'This is It' I think
Jackson was a genius far above any of the others on that list. This is coming from a lifetime musician who has toured, and played in bands my whole life ]

Spike Lee On Michael Jackson's Evolution From Child Star To 'Off The Wall'


<time datetime="2016-02-05T14:51:00-05:00" style="box-sizing: border-box; margin: 0px; padding: 0px; border: 0px; font-style: inherit; font-variant: inherit; font-weight: inherit; font-stretch: inherit; font-size: inherit; line-height: inherit; font-family: inherit; vertical-align: baseline;">Updated February 5, 20162:51 PM ETPublished February 5, 20165:12 AM ET</time>


MANDALIT DEL BARCO









Listen to the Story

Morning Edition
3:51






p16-19615-adv01_mj_affiliateposter_wide-cd26f2e83eb4b21b17cf6fc56570c7de597a2cb9-s800-c85.jpg

Spike Lee's new documentary charts the King of Pop's journey from child stardom to early fame as a solo act.

Courtesy of SHOWTIME


Tonight, Showtime presents a new documentary on the late pop star Michael Jackson, called Michael Jackson's Journey from Motown to Off the Wall. Director Spike Lee explores his journey from child prodigy to recording his best-selling 1979 album. It's the second in what Lee hopes will be a trilogy of films dedicated to Jackson's musical legacy.
Off the Wall was Michael Jackson's first solo album as an adult.
"That's the first time we heard that iconic yell," says musician Questlove. "That's his 'Free at last/ free at last.' "
Questlove is one of many who reflect on Jackson's hit dance songs and R&B ballads from that album.
Spike Lee's documentary traces Jackson's journey from being a child star with the Jackson 5 at Motown to becoming a superstar solo act with Epic Records.
Michael Jackson's evolution to being the confident 20-year-old heard in Off the Wall is all here in the film. It includes archival recordings from TV shows and private interviews with the soft-spoken star at his home.
Jackson is shown learning from his idols: Quincy Jones and Stevie Wonder, Sammy Davis Jr., Fred Astaire and Gene Kelly. There's rarely seen footage of Jackson tap dancing with the legendary Nicholas brothers. And a host of people, from actress Rosie Perez to basketball star Kobe Bryant, talk about how Jackson's perfectionism inspired them.
Michael Jackson died after an overdose, just before he turned 51, on the eve of his "This Is It" tour. With this film, his estate is preserving his legacy, says co-executor John Branca.
"We are approached constantly from all over the world, from people wanting to do Michael Jackson projects," Branca says. "But it's more important to say no than it is to say yes. We just want to be very selective. We thought Spike was the ideal choice for director. He's very passionate."
The estate first hired Spike Lee to direct a documentary on Jackson's album Bad. A few weeks ago, before the Sundance Film festival premiere of this new film, Lee said he didn't want to touch on anything negative surrounding Jackson's life or death.
"I told them from the get-go," Lee says, "we were going to focus on the music: his genius, the dance, the songwriting. All that other stuff, we're not dealing with. That's for somebody else to do. Not me. I'm not doing it."
Lee directed Jackson's music videos for his 1996 song "They Don't Care About Us." And he's hosted several block parties in Brooklyn to celebrate the King of Pop.
"Michael is alive, because his music is still here," Lee says. "And every year a new generation is introduced to MJ."




Every time Michael Jackson sang the song "She's Out of My Life," he cried, Quincy Jones recalls in the documentary. He produced Off the Wall. Three years later, in 1983, Jackson recorded Thriller, which won eight Grammys and remains the best-selling album of all time.
Spike Lee says he hopes to be able to chronicle that in his third Michael Jackson documentary.


images

 

Nirvana Shill
Joined
Oct 20, 2001
Messages
28,609
Tokens
all of them are talented but Joel is far behind the other three imo
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2003
Messages
26,300
Tokens
Great 4 names but it should have been expanded to top ten....Roy Orbison deserves more love....
 
Joined
Sep 14, 2007
Messages
5,579
Tokens
I wonder how many people posting judgements in this thread have even a clue about music theory and song-writing.

If you don't think Michael Jackson was a musical genius, watch the DVD "This is It." And, keep in mind that he wrote all the music and lyrics to all the songs, wrote the dance choreography, and had it all memorized in his head enough to correct all the musicians who were trying to back him up.

I don't even particularly like most of Jackson's music, it's not a style that I like per se, but I have no problem acknowledging the guy was a musical genius - more-so than the others on the list, who's music style-wise I like a lot more.

Best singer: Elvis then Elton/Joel, then Jackson
Best Musician: Jackson, then Joel, then Elton, then Elvis
Best Dancer/Video Star: Jackson
Best Entertainer: Jackson
Best Overall: Jackson
Michael Jackson didn't even play an instrument and couldn't read music yet you say he is the best musician of the group? Your bias is obvious.

The fact is all 4 of these guys are great talents in their own way and none of them are miles ahead of the others like some in here want to believe. Pretty even group if you ask me.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,879
Tokens
Michael Jackson didn't even play an instrument and couldn't read music yet you say he is the best musician of the group? Your bias is obvious.

The fact is all 4 of these guys are great talents in their own way and none of them are miles ahead of the others like some in here want to believe. Pretty even group if you ask me.

My bias is obvious? ROFL. I don't even like his music, and I think he's a pedophile. How's that for bias, idiot.

Fact is, ask the experts - watch the documentaries... it's not even close.

Do your homework before you post stupid shit.

Oh, and by the way, he's credited for playing: keyboard, synthesizer, guitar, drums and percussion on 'HIStory'
 

Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2008
Messages
2,660
Tokens
Michael Jackson didn't even play an instrument and couldn't read music yet you say he is the best musician of the group? Your bias is obvious.

The fact is all 4 of these guys are great talents in their own way and none of them are miles ahead of the others like some in here want to believe. Pretty even group if you ask me.

could play any instrument same as prince
 
Joined
Sep 14, 2007
Messages
5,579
Tokens
My bias is obvious? ROFL. I don't even like his music, and I think he's a pedophile. How's that for bias, idiot.

Fact is, ask the experts - watch the documentaries... it's not even close.

Do your homework before you post stupid shit.

Oh, and by the way, he's credited for playing: keyboard, synthesizer, guitar, drums and percussion on 'HIStory'
Oh please, ask the experts and watch the documentaries? It's an opinion question and everyone has different opinions. Im sure I can search and find plenty of "experts and documentaries" that will say Joel, Elton or Elvis is the best ever. But you're an asshole so it doesn't surprise me you would respond to me this way. And I could watch 100 random music videos of MJ right now and chances are I wouldn't see him play an instrument in any of them. But he is by far the best "musician" of the group, lol.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,879
Tokens
Oh please, ask the experts and watch the documentaries? It's an opinion question and everyone has different opinions. Im sure I can search and find plenty of "experts and documentaries" that will say Joel, Elton or Elvis is the best ever. But you're an asshole so it doesn't surprise me you would respond to me this way. And I could watch 100 random music videos of MJ right now and chances are I wouldn't see him play an instrument in any of them. But he is by far the best "musician" of the group, lol.

Um, the thread doesn't ask who is "by far the best *musician* of the group." It's no surprise that you try to twist things to justify your
ignorant statements, being that you sir are an asshole, AND have a single digit IQ. Pull your panties out of your vagina, and take it from a lifetime musician who actually knows what he's talking about, you are wrong yet again.
 
Joined
Sep 14, 2007
Messages
5,579
Tokens
Um, the thread doesn't ask who is "by far the best *musician* of the group." It's no surprise that you try to twist things to justify your
ignorant statements, being that you sir are an asshole, AND have a single digit IQ. Pull your panties out of your vagina, and take it from a lifetime musician who actually knows what he's talking about, you are wrong yet again.
No, it doesn't, but you felt the need to post that he is the best musician. Why did you post that if its not what the thread is about? So it seems you twisted things first. I only pointed out I didn't feel he is the best musician based on the fact that actually playing an instrument is not something he does. My response to that was very civilized but you felt the need to respond back in your usual manner, with insults. So yes, I called you an asshole because it's true.

What really gets to me about you is this is an opinion poll. It's about music which everyone has a different taste so obviously everyone's opinion will be different. But you don't even have an opinion of your own. You have to post articles that others write and then say because the "experts" say it, then it must be true. That's not your opinion, it's theirs. Why don't you try and post your own opinion for a change instead of being a "follower".

There is no right or wrong here. But obviously, you are too fucking stupid to realize that because all you do is follow what others say instead of thinking for yourself.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,879
Tokens
No, it doesn't, but you felt the need to post that he is the best musician. Why did you post that if its not what the thread is about? So it seems you twisted things first. I only pointed out I didn't feel he is the best musician based on the fact that actually playing an instrument is not something he does. My response to that was very civilized but you felt the need to respond back in your usual manner, with insults. So yes, I called you an asshole because it's true.

What really gets to me about you is this is an opinion poll. It's about music which everyone has a different taste so obviously everyone's opinion will be different. But you don't even have an opinion of your own. You have to post articles that others write and then say because the "experts" say it, then it must be true. That's not your opinion, it's theirs. Why don't you try and post your own opinion for a change instead of being a "follower".

There is no right or wrong here. But obviously, you are too fucking stupid to realize that because all you do is follow what others say instead of thinking for yourself.


Um, stop lying and twisting what I said asshole.

#1. I never said he was the best musician, so the main point you're trying to make is a complete lie. It's only a couple posts back (#68), and I already pointed this out to you, but you're so fucking dense and stupid, you still can't figure it out.

#2. Your response that started this was not "very civilized." You made a snotty remark that "Your bias is obvious." even though I explained twice that I'm not even a fan of his music.

#3. You're too stupid to realize that I'm am posting my opinion, and I'm buttressing it with the opinions of the experts in the field. In all seriousness,
I honestly think you have serious deficiencies in the IQ department, you have to be one of the most dense and obtuse posters in here.
 
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
44,879
Tokens
Mea Culpa.

I do see that 3 years ago in the thread, I posted that I thought Michael was the best musician. I still think an argument can be made that that is true, given that two documentaries I sited showed that he could sing the parts of all the instruments in a song... but Wabash has a valid point there.

My bad, I apologize, I was wrong 100%. I'm the asshole, and I take responsibility for being wrong.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,110,385
Messages
13,469,328
Members
99,547
Latest member
mariataylor1
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com