Seattle and Minnesota try to deal with RB injuries
Eric Karabell
ESPN INSIDER
10/6/17
There’s a difference between recommending a new starting running back because you really like him and think he’ll be really productive and talking about a player just because he suddenly has the opportunity. That’s kind of how I feel about the running back situations for both the Minnesota Vikings and Seattle Seahawks after they each lost exciting rookie starters, Dalvin Cook and Chris Carson, respectively, to season-ending leg injuries. Sure, Latavius Murray and Eddie Lacy have each had seasons in the past when fantasy owners loved them and they’ll be relevant in Week 5. Still, it seems unlikely we’ll love them in 2017.
Murray was the more popular pickup compared to longtime backup Jerick McKinnon -- and he should be, as the Vikings went to him on Sunday after the Cook injury and figure to give him the larger workload. The problem, of course, is that Murray isn’t that good to start with and he’s still dealing with ankle soreness after offseason surgery. So, when many of us advise fantasy owners to add Murray to their teams -- and people are so desperate that he’s up to 80 percent rostered -- it shouldn’t be construed as blind faith for another 1,000-yard rushing season or a repeat of last year's 12 touchdowns.
The Vikings are likely to use Murray on early downs and McKinnon on passing downs, and it would be surprising if Stevan Ridley, signed Thursday after last playing a key role for a team in 2014, mattered. It might just be that, like several other NFL squads -- the Giants and Cardinals jump to mind -- there simply might not be any Vikings running back that will truly matter statistically. We’ll all be watching Monday night, and perhaps Murray will be awesome. Then again, despite my RB2 ranking for him, I do have reservations.
My best guess for the Seahawks is that both Lacy and Thomas Rawls get some opportunities and whichever one ends up being more productive is the one who will keep getting touches. Lacy was the more popular fantasy addition this week -- and that makes sense, for he likely gets the first shot. After all, he’s the one who ran 11 times for 52 yards against the Colts in Week 4 and, at times, looked somewhat more competent than the others. He’s not fast. He's far from svelte. Heck, he's not much of a pass-catcher, either. Oh, and the Seattle offensive line has big problems opening up reasonable holes to run through. Other than that, it’s a Super Bowl-contending team. Ha!
Rawls was a healthy scratch in Week 4, but wasn’t healthy prior to that. He also doesn’t catch passes. C.J. Prosise does, but he’s got a sprained ankle, didn’t play the past two games and didn’t practice Wednesday. Prosise, when healthy and available, could be like Cleveland’s Duke Johnson Jr. -- a fun pass-catcher who rises up to become the most valuable fantasy asset among his team’s running backs. But Prosise seldom seems to be able to stay healthy and available. There’s also J.D. McKissic to consider, as he turned his five touches from scrimmage into 65 yards and two touchdowns on Sunday night. Don’t discount his potential relevance. We watch because we care, and any of Lacy, Rawls, Prosise and McKissic could end up being valuable. For now, I’d roster them in that order. Still, try to avoid relying on any of these guys.
Top-20 running back watch: This is becoming a weekly section in this “What to Watch For” space because fantasy owners are desperate for running back help, especially with the bye weeks beginning and Devonta Freeman, C.J. Anderson and others unavailable. This week, we continue to watch in relative amazement as Cincinnati Bengals rookie Joe Mixon fails to emerge as the team’s lead back, despite much evidence he should. Carolina Panthers pass-catching back Christian McCaffrey continues to frustrate as well. You know what? Mixon and McCaffrey were both comfortably assigned to our collective top 20 for Week 5, in part because there’s nobody else to nominate, but also for the upside we keep discussing but have yet to truly see. Continue to invest in them. Last week, we focused on Cleveland’s Isaiah Crowell and the Jets’ Bilal Powell in the hopes of finding some clarity, but didn’t really get any answers. Perhaps this week a few rookies will break out to take their place.
Revenge is a dish best served in Indy: Or something like that. The point is that the Indianapolis Colts face the San Francisco 49ers this week, and veteran running back Frank Gore faces the team for which he played an excellent 10 seasons. Gore isn’t off to such a great statistical start in 2017, as he ranks just 30th in PPR scoring after having finished last year just outside the top 10. Fantasy owners aren’t dropping him, but they’re probably not excited about activating him, either. Well, the ESPN rankers have him easily in the top 20 at running back. No, he hasn’t gotten any younger, but it doesn’t look like he has hit some imaginary wall either, despite the tepid performance. A tough schedule and the loss of quarterback Andrew Luck haven’t helped. One could easily argue that Gore is someone to trade for in fantasy, though I wouldn’t give up a lot for him. The 49ers have permitted the fourth-most fantasy points (PPR) to running backs, and three of Gore’s five catches on the season came Sunday at Seattle. Perhaps he’ll be more active in that department moving forward.
More rookie talk: Then there’s the other side of the Monday night game in which the Chicago Bears turn to No. 2 overall draft pick Mitchell Trubisky to save them. Well, perhaps not save them, but at least to gain some valuable experience and perform better than Mike Glennon did. That, at least, seems attainable. While my general feeling about trusting rookie quarterbacks is always something along the lines of it not being a good idea, Houston’s Deshaun Watson looks fantastic and Cleveland’s DeShone Kizer -- well, things take time. I wouldn’t even roster Trubisky in a re-draft, 10-team standard league. In a dynasty format I would because he really could be valuable in a year. Perhaps he follows the Jared Goff path and looks completely out of place his first season but ends up emerging in Year 2 thanks to some offensive line help, more weapons and better playcalling. Things like this don’t surprise me much anymore. Fantasy owners should watch the initial effect on running backs Jordan Howard and Tarik Cohen and whether any wide receivers become potential flex options. For now, however, don’t downgrade Howard and Cohen or roster the likes of Kendall Wright in shallow formats. Don’t be surprised if this works out, though. You never know.
Eric Karabell
ESPN INSIDER
10/6/17
There’s a difference between recommending a new starting running back because you really like him and think he’ll be really productive and talking about a player just because he suddenly has the opportunity. That’s kind of how I feel about the running back situations for both the Minnesota Vikings and Seattle Seahawks after they each lost exciting rookie starters, Dalvin Cook and Chris Carson, respectively, to season-ending leg injuries. Sure, Latavius Murray and Eddie Lacy have each had seasons in the past when fantasy owners loved them and they’ll be relevant in Week 5. Still, it seems unlikely we’ll love them in 2017.
Murray was the more popular pickup compared to longtime backup Jerick McKinnon -- and he should be, as the Vikings went to him on Sunday after the Cook injury and figure to give him the larger workload. The problem, of course, is that Murray isn’t that good to start with and he’s still dealing with ankle soreness after offseason surgery. So, when many of us advise fantasy owners to add Murray to their teams -- and people are so desperate that he’s up to 80 percent rostered -- it shouldn’t be construed as blind faith for another 1,000-yard rushing season or a repeat of last year's 12 touchdowns.
The Vikings are likely to use Murray on early downs and McKinnon on passing downs, and it would be surprising if Stevan Ridley, signed Thursday after last playing a key role for a team in 2014, mattered. It might just be that, like several other NFL squads -- the Giants and Cardinals jump to mind -- there simply might not be any Vikings running back that will truly matter statistically. We’ll all be watching Monday night, and perhaps Murray will be awesome. Then again, despite my RB2 ranking for him, I do have reservations.
My best guess for the Seahawks is that both Lacy and Thomas Rawls get some opportunities and whichever one ends up being more productive is the one who will keep getting touches. Lacy was the more popular fantasy addition this week -- and that makes sense, for he likely gets the first shot. After all, he’s the one who ran 11 times for 52 yards against the Colts in Week 4 and, at times, looked somewhat more competent than the others. He’s not fast. He's far from svelte. Heck, he's not much of a pass-catcher, either. Oh, and the Seattle offensive line has big problems opening up reasonable holes to run through. Other than that, it’s a Super Bowl-contending team. Ha!
Rawls was a healthy scratch in Week 4, but wasn’t healthy prior to that. He also doesn’t catch passes. C.J. Prosise does, but he’s got a sprained ankle, didn’t play the past two games and didn’t practice Wednesday. Prosise, when healthy and available, could be like Cleveland’s Duke Johnson Jr. -- a fun pass-catcher who rises up to become the most valuable fantasy asset among his team’s running backs. But Prosise seldom seems to be able to stay healthy and available. There’s also J.D. McKissic to consider, as he turned his five touches from scrimmage into 65 yards and two touchdowns on Sunday night. Don’t discount his potential relevance. We watch because we care, and any of Lacy, Rawls, Prosise and McKissic could end up being valuable. For now, I’d roster them in that order. Still, try to avoid relying on any of these guys.
Top-20 running back watch: This is becoming a weekly section in this “What to Watch For” space because fantasy owners are desperate for running back help, especially with the bye weeks beginning and Devonta Freeman, C.J. Anderson and others unavailable. This week, we continue to watch in relative amazement as Cincinnati Bengals rookie Joe Mixon fails to emerge as the team’s lead back, despite much evidence he should. Carolina Panthers pass-catching back Christian McCaffrey continues to frustrate as well. You know what? Mixon and McCaffrey were both comfortably assigned to our collective top 20 for Week 5, in part because there’s nobody else to nominate, but also for the upside we keep discussing but have yet to truly see. Continue to invest in them. Last week, we focused on Cleveland’s Isaiah Crowell and the Jets’ Bilal Powell in the hopes of finding some clarity, but didn’t really get any answers. Perhaps this week a few rookies will break out to take their place.
Revenge is a dish best served in Indy: Or something like that. The point is that the Indianapolis Colts face the San Francisco 49ers this week, and veteran running back Frank Gore faces the team for which he played an excellent 10 seasons. Gore isn’t off to such a great statistical start in 2017, as he ranks just 30th in PPR scoring after having finished last year just outside the top 10. Fantasy owners aren’t dropping him, but they’re probably not excited about activating him, either. Well, the ESPN rankers have him easily in the top 20 at running back. No, he hasn’t gotten any younger, but it doesn’t look like he has hit some imaginary wall either, despite the tepid performance. A tough schedule and the loss of quarterback Andrew Luck haven’t helped. One could easily argue that Gore is someone to trade for in fantasy, though I wouldn’t give up a lot for him. The 49ers have permitted the fourth-most fantasy points (PPR) to running backs, and three of Gore’s five catches on the season came Sunday at Seattle. Perhaps he’ll be more active in that department moving forward.
More rookie talk: Then there’s the other side of the Monday night game in which the Chicago Bears turn to No. 2 overall draft pick Mitchell Trubisky to save them. Well, perhaps not save them, but at least to gain some valuable experience and perform better than Mike Glennon did. That, at least, seems attainable. While my general feeling about trusting rookie quarterbacks is always something along the lines of it not being a good idea, Houston’s Deshaun Watson looks fantastic and Cleveland’s DeShone Kizer -- well, things take time. I wouldn’t even roster Trubisky in a re-draft, 10-team standard league. In a dynasty format I would because he really could be valuable in a year. Perhaps he follows the Jared Goff path and looks completely out of place his first season but ends up emerging in Year 2 thanks to some offensive line help, more weapons and better playcalling. Things like this don’t surprise me much anymore. Fantasy owners should watch the initial effect on running backs Jordan Howard and Tarik Cohen and whether any wide receivers become potential flex options. For now, however, don’t downgrade Howard and Cohen or roster the likes of Kendall Wright in shallow formats. Don’t be surprised if this works out, though. You never know.