Andrew Luck will never win a Super Bowl

[Defying]

I fully believe that. Media has already sold him as the next Manning and that stock is so overvalued.

 

[HarryCaray]

This is spillover from an argument I had with Mr Defying. Let me tell you all he is an Andrew Luck HATER. Not sure why. But he literally told me that Tannehill is better than Luck.

I offered him a wager that at the end of the 2017 season he would have 25k yards, 200TD, and a ring...he declined.

Enough said

 

[Defying]

I'm so impressed he competed 58% of his passes... and won divisions against the jaguars, titans and texans.

 

[scottcarter]

A lot of things must go right in order to win a super bowl. Arguably the greatest QB Dan Marino never won one. Trent Dilfer did. I am not sold on the Colt's running game yet but if they can get that going, they could go deep in the playoffs and maybe win the super bowl this year.

 

[Defying]

This is spillover for an argument I had with Mr Defying. Let me tell you all he is an Andrew Luck HATER. Not sure why. But he literally told me that Tannehill is better than Luck.

I offered him a wager that at the end of the 2017 season he would have 25k yards, 200TD, and a ring...he declined.

Enough said

I believe I said I fully accept. he won win a ring

 

[loomis41973]

I fully believe that. Media has already sold him as the next Manning and that stock is so overvalued.

Overvalued? Who is better at his age?

 

[JustinCruise]

defying hno:

 

[Defying]

Why is Andrew Luck Special?

Because he plays for Colts and audibles and reminds people of Manning

 

[PatsFan1283]

numbers? team record?

not sure what metric you need to tell you he has a bright future

 

[scottcarter]

7th straight 300+ game

 

[Defying]

I know I can't win this arguement today.... but years from now im looking forward to bumping this...

 

[HarryCaray]

I'm so impressed he competed 58% of his passes...

58% career completion percentage is misleading, he's improving. 54% rookie year, 58% last year, 65% this year.

If you can't see the trajectory that his career is currently on, I don't know what to tell ya.

 

[scottcarter]

I know I can't win this arguement today.... but years from now im looking forward to bumping this...

you might not be able to after just over 3 months from now k:

 

[HarryCaray]

numbers? team record?

not sure what metric you need to tell you he has a bright future

Thank you, that's exactly what I've been saying.

His comebacks are: Tannehill has a higher completion percentage, and he plays in a weak division.

 

[Defying]

Luck has the best situation imaginable. He's played with a great D... He has always had a OL... He has extremely talented WRs.... He plays in the worst division in football by a mile... IMO, he's at the pinnacle of his career...

Media just loves him. Every one assumes he's the best. Tonight Gruden said "he's barely missed any passes" When he was 22 of 42... Only missed 20 completions....

 

[PatsFan1283]

I know I can't win this arguement today.... but years from now im looking forward to bumping this...

you know I cameup with this on my own and it is a hell of a theory so hopefully it won't blow anyones mind too much

but it is almost as if winning a superbowl and being as good as Peyton Manning aren't mutually exclusive

 

[PatsFan1283]

Luck has the best situation imaginable. He's played with a great D... He has always had a OL... He has extremely talented WRs.... He plays in the worst division in football by a mile... IMO, he's at the pinnacle of his career...

Media just loves him. Every one assumes he's the best. Tonight Gruden said "he's barely missed any passes" When he was 22 of 42... Only missed 20 completions....

Always had a OL

LOL

is RX traffic low or something?

 

[scottcarter]

Luck has the best situation imaginable. He's played with a great D... He has always had a OL... He has extremely talented WRs.... He plays in the worst division in football by a mile... IMO, he's at the pinnacle of his career...

Media just loves him. Every one assumes he's the best. Tonight Gruden said "he's barely missed any passes" When he was 22 of 42... Only missed 20 completions....

so how to you rate Mannings performance in last year's Super Bowl?

dangerous to hand pick certain stats in certain games.

 

[HarryCaray]

Media just loves him. Every one assumes he's the best. Tonight Gruden said "he's barely missed any passes" When he was 22 of 42... Only missed 20 completions....

That's your hangup, you're obsessed with what the media thinks about him. Who cares that Gruden has a boner for him? That doesn't make him any less special.

Defying told me he thought Bumgarner was "over valued" after the WS, just cause the media was on his jock. Sigh

 

[PatsFan1283]

How can you say the AFC South is bad?

It's like Roy Jones Jr used to say "They say I ain't beat nobody, I just make em look like nobody!"

Ok the AFC South really does suck, but I figured I needed a comment of my own to match Defyings insanity in this thread