Its hard to overlook Cobb, I think what hurts TY is he was an outfielder, and not a whole lot of power, although if I`m not mistaken, Ty did lead the league in home runs a couple times before the ball was livened....
jatee, no doubt Murray`s best year was going to be 1981, he was on a great pace with about 1/3 a season left...His RBI numbers are there, and like i said he never played for high scoring teams...
Edgar Martinez may be the best second half of a career there ever was...He didn t get cranked up til he was in his 30`s...Edgar could hit for another 5 years easy!