That seems to be a list of pitchers that were great/good that now suck. So Tim Redding? I'm sorry, but that guy was never that good. Doesn't belong there. Give Zito more time, he's been great in his past two starts. Maddux isn't a hasbeen, he's a 40-year-old pitcher who's one of the greatest ever, who is just pitching a little past his prime. Can't call him a hasbeen; call him a hall of famer. Oliver Perez had one good year, but I still wanna see more of him. Either he'll get out of his funk or be a scrub, but you can't call him a hasbeen when he's only been good for one year.
As for Schmidt, he had a rought start today, no doubt, but he was pitching well before that. Give him the entire year, at least. The guy's only one of the winningest pitchers of the past few years, and most dominant. So I think he deserves more than an injury-plagued 2004 and one rough outing against a Nats team that has recorded 10 or more hits in their fifth straight game.
Just my opinion, though.