Who was better Derek Jeter or Cal Ripken Jr?

Search

Who's better Derek Jeter or Cal Ripken Jr?

  • Cal Ripken Jr

    Votes: 13 44.8%
  • Derek Jeter

    Votes: 16 55.2%

  • Total voters
    29

Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2008
Messages
8,145
Tokens
Bottom line Jeter is/Was a very Good Ballplayer... He was never in the News with Bad Press. As far as anyone knows, he played the game Clean.
Have dated a ton of Hot Girls... Not a known Diva ( like A-Roid ) and he played to the Limit.
Only people that have something bad to say are NY Met and Red Sox Fans.

What I Like about him is he is a True Yankee ( from their Farm System ) and not paid for by the Evil Empire.. lol
I also like that he gives a lot back. and more so with Kids.... which is our Future.

The Guy is a role model. End of Story.


I agree but same goes for cal. He even moved to third for mike bordick, lol.
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
Bottom line Jeter is/Was a very Good Ballplayer... He was never in the News with Bad Press. As far as anyone knows, he played the game Clean.
Have dated a ton of Hot Girls... Not a known Diva ( like A-Roid ) and he played to the Limit.
Only people that have something bad to say are NY Met and Red Sox Fans.

What I Like about him is he is a True Yankee ( from their Farm System ) and not paid for by the Evil Empire.. lol
I also like that he gives a lot back. and more so with Kids.... which is our Future.

The Guy is a role model. End of Story.
In your opinion does he deserve to be a first ballot hall of famer?
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
In your opinion does he deserve to be a first ballot hall of famer?

first ballot ? Yes

Look at his numbers from 1996 to 2012

CAREER BATTING STATISTICS
YEARTEAMGPABRH2B3BHRRBIBBSOSBCSAVGOBPSLGOPSWAR
1995
1548512410731100.250.294.375.669-0.4
1996
157582104183256107848102147.314.370.430.8003.0
1997
1596541161903171070741252312.291.370.405.7754.8
1998
149626127203258198457119306.324.384.481.8657.3
1999
1586271342193792410291116198.349.438.552.9907.8
2000
14859311920131415736899224.339.416.481.8974.4
2001
15061411019135321745699273.311.377.480.8574.9
2002
157644124191260187573114323.297.373.421.7943.5
2003
1194828715625310524388115.324.393.450.8433.4
2004
15464311118844123784699234.292.352.471.8234.1
2005
159654122202255197077117145.309.389.450.8393.7
2006
154623118214393149769102345.343.417.483.9005.4
2007
156639102206394127356100158.322.388.452.8403.7
2008
1505968817925311695285115.300.363.408.7712.7
2009
15363410721227118667290305.334.406.465.8716.4
2010
157663111179303106763106185.270.340.370.7101.6
2011
131546841622446614681166.297.355.388.7430.9
2012
159683992163201558459094.316.362.429.7912.1
2013
1763812101781000.190.288.254.542-0.7
2014
143577471471914493586102.255.302.312.6140.1
TotalTotal274511191192334635446626013101082183935897.309.377.440.817--
Season Averages137.0559.696.2173.227.23.313.065.554.192.017.94.9.309.377.440.817--

<tbody>
</tbody>
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
You homer.

No way first ballot. Look at all the others that were way better that were not first ballot.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Jan 15, 2010
Messages
26,074
Tokens
So the question is which player was the least overated

Yeah I thought they were the most similar. I don't follow baseball players too closely only teams and who wins the games.
I was listening to a sports radio show this morning and they asked someone this question, and when he answered Cal, they all called him a homer, so was wondering where the betting public was on this.
 

Conservatives, Patriots & Huskies return to glory
Handicapper
Joined
Sep 9, 2005
Messages
85,814
Tokens
Runs 1923 vs 1647
Hits 3463 vs 3184
Avg 309 vs 276
OBP 377 vs 340
HR 260 vs 431
RBI 1310 vs 1695
2B 544 vs 603
3B 66 vs 44
SB 358 vs 36

Cal has the power #'s, Jeter has everything else

I think Jeter wins the intangibles, and I think Jeter's post season accomplishments are off the charts (I understand Cal didn't have the opportunities, but that's life)


Jeter hands down
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
Start naming them .... it took Yaz 23 years to hit 3400+ hits, took Jeter 20 years

How many of those guys sat on one of their final games after "an emotional" home game?
 

Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2012
Messages
22,469
Tokens
I think you can make a credible argument that Jeter is the 2nd best SS behind Wagner.

He played in 158 post season games and had 200 hits (20 HR's) against the best competition. Added to the fact that in a big spot, the other team did not want him at the plate and the other team's fans were in a panic when he stepped to the plate in a post season game.
He also never made a key mistake in the post season. Not 1 I can think of.

That sums it up for me.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
How many of those guys sat on one of their final games after "an emotional" home game?

Like he said, he wanted to leave something "Special" for the Fans at Yankee stadium.
If the Season ended at Home, he would be playing SS
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
"If the Season ended at Home, he would be playing SS"

I'm not sure what that means....his team is in Boston, not Ny. You have to play the schedule right?
I know he was a healthy scratch tonight.
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
"If the Season ended at Home, he would be playing SS"

I'm not sure what that means....his team is in Boston, not Ny. You have to play the schedule right?
I know he was a healthy scratch tonight.

Guess this might not have made it up in the Boston papers or News.

This is what Jeter said last night after the game

Jeter said he would be back in the lineup on Saturday and Sunday - but as designated hitter, so his final memories as a shortstop would be in Yankee Stadium. Girardi told Jeter he could play any position but pitcher or catcher this weekend if he had the urge - including manager.

Jeter declined.


Here is the Full story as to why he Optioned Out of the Line-up tonight.


BOSTON (AP) -- Nineteen years into his Hall of Fame career, Derek Jeter may have produced his final ''first.''
<section class="yom-mod " id="mediacontentrelatedstory" data-ylk="mid:mediacontentrelatedstory;mpos:1;elm:hdln;elmt:ct;cat:Related Stories;rspns:nav;t1:a3;t2:lst-ct;itc:0;sec:lst-ct;"> Related Stories






</section>


The New York Yankees shortstop asked out of the lineup for Friday night's game against the Boston Red Sox - something neither Jeter nor manager Joe Girardi could remember him ever doing before.
Jeter watched the opener of his final major league series from the dugout, taking it easy a day after his walk-off single finished off an emotional farewell to Yankee Stadium.
''I don't think I really slept - maybe a couple of hours,'' Jeter told reporters. ''I don't know if I could play tonight if I was playing tonight. Last night was as special as it gets.''
Since announcing in spring training that this would be his final season, Jeter has been celebrated across the major leagues, collecting gifts at each stop and applause from former opponents and their fans. Then came his final home game, when the pregame cheers were surpassed by the postgame celebration after he led the Yankees to another win.
''I was thinking how fitting it was, what a great night it was,'' Girardi said before Friday's game. ''I'm sure he's emotionally drained, probably physically drained.''
View gallery

Fans surround the New York Yankees dugout as shortstop Derek Jeter heads to the clubhouse prior to t …

With both the Yankees and Red Sox eliminated from playoff contention, Girardi compiled a lineup missing many of his regulars and joked that it looked more like spring training roster. Eury Perez batted in Jeter's familiar No. 2 spot - and collected his first major league hit - and Brendan Ryan played shortstop.
Jeter said he would be back in the lineup on Saturday and Sunday - but as designated hitter, so his final memories as a shortstop would be in Yankee Stadium. Girardi told Jeter he could play any position but pitcher or catcher this weekend if he had the urge - including manager.
Jeter declined.
''I don't pay attention enough,'' he said. ''When I'm not playing, I'm all over the place.''
A 14-time All-Star and five-time World Series champion, Jeter has collected 3,463 hits in his career along with the near-universal respect from teammates and opponents alike. Even in Boston, where fans hate the Yankees like no other team, most of the animosity was reserved for Alex Rodriguez or Red Sox defectors like Johnny Damon and Roger Clemens.
View gallery

New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter adjusts his cap as he talks with reporters prior to the Yanke …

The sold-out crowd, peppered with fans in pinstriped No. 2 jerseys, chanted Jeter's name in the second inning - something that would not have been tolerated a decade ago, when Bostonians wore profane T-shirts about Jeter and argued that Nomar Garciaparra was a better shortstop.
Since then, though, the Red Sox have ended their eight-decade World Series drought - winning three titles in 10 years, in fact - and the rivalry has lost some of its edge.
''I think after they won - I don't want to say they softened up, I would say I think they're kinder,'' said Jeter, who ventured onto the streets of Boston for lunch on Friday afternoon and was greeted warmly. ''People were saying, 'Congratulations for the career. I'm a Red Sox fan and I hate the Yankees, but I respect you.'
''Even when I was walking here through the stands, people were cheering. I remember in 1999, when I was here for the All-Star Game ... I remember getting out of the car and I thought they were going to kill me. Funny how things have changed.''
And the feeling is mutual.
View gallery

New York Yankees' Derek Jeter (2) is mobbed by teammates after driving in the winning run with a …

Although his night off no doubt disappointed those who bought a ticket for an otherwise meaningless game hoping to see a part of history, Jeter said he would play the final two games of the season out of respect for the rivalry.
''It's always difficult at this point because everybody wants to see him,'' Girardi said. ''I think Derek understands the magnitude of the rivalry and the importance of it in the game of baseball. ... I think there's a huge amount of respect too for what these organizations have done for the game of baseball.''
Red Sox manager John Farrell said Jeter's Yankee Stadium finale was special, and he expects the good feelings to surround this weekend, too.
''The game has an incredible way of creating unique opportunities,'' Farrell said. ''His 3,000th hit is a solo home run, his last at-bat at Yankee Stadium is a walk-off. The game provides us opportunities that embed memories, and that's certainly one of them.''
Elsewhere in baseball, they were also talking about Jeter.
''When you look at great players, you look at them as the heat turns up, they get calm,'' Washington Nationals manager Matt Williams said. ''Not everybody can do that. But he's one of them that can. ... That's why he got the hit last night. Because the situation is never too big for him.''
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
Guess this might not have made it up in the Boston papers or News.

This is what Jeter said last night after the game

Jeter said he would be back in the lineup on Saturday and Sunday - but as designated hitter, so his final memories as a shortstop would be in Yankee Stadium. Girardi told Jeter he could play any position but pitcher or catcher this weekend if he had the urge - including manager.

Jeter declined.


Here is the Full story as to why he Optioned Out of the Line-up tonight.


BOSTON (AP) -- Nineteen years into his Hall of Fame career, Derek Jeter may have produced his final ''first.''
<section class="yom-mod " id="mediacontentrelatedstory" data-ylk="mid:mediacontentrelatedstory;mpos:1;elm:hdln;elmt:ct;cat:Related Stories;rspns:nav;t1:a3;t2:lst-ct;itc:0;sec:lst-ct;"> Related Stories






</section>


The New York Yankees shortstop asked out of the lineup for Friday night's game against the Boston Red Sox - something neither Jeter nor manager Joe Girardi could remember him ever doing before.
Jeter watched the opener of his final major league series from the dugout, taking it easy a day after his walk-off single finished off an emotional farewell to Yankee Stadium.
''I don't think I really slept - maybe a couple of hours,'' Jeter told reporters. ''I don't know if I could play tonight if I was playing tonight. Last night was as special as it gets.''
Since announcing in spring training that this would be his final season, Jeter has been celebrated across the major leagues, collecting gifts at each stop and applause from former opponents and their fans. Then came his final home game, when the pregame cheers were surpassed by the postgame celebration after he led the Yankees to another win.
''I was thinking how fitting it was, what a great night it was,'' Girardi said before Friday's game. ''I'm sure he's emotionally drained, probably physically drained.''
View gallery

Fans surround the New York Yankees dugout as shortstop Derek Jeter heads to the clubhouse prior to t …

With both the Yankees and Red Sox eliminated from playoff contention, Girardi compiled a lineup missing many of his regulars and joked that it looked more like spring training roster. Eury Perez batted in Jeter's familiar No. 2 spot - and collected his first major league hit - and Brendan Ryan played shortstop.
Jeter said he would be back in the lineup on Saturday and Sunday - but as designated hitter, so his final memories as a shortstop would be in Yankee Stadium. Girardi told Jeter he could play any position but pitcher or catcher this weekend if he had the urge - including manager.
Jeter declined.
''I don't pay attention enough,'' he said. ''When I'm not playing, I'm all over the place.''
A 14-time All-Star and five-time World Series champion, Jeter has collected 3,463 hits in his career along with the near-universal respect from teammates and opponents alike. Even in Boston, where fans hate the Yankees like no other team, most of the animosity was reserved for Alex Rodriguez or Red Sox defectors like Johnny Damon and Roger Clemens.
View gallery

New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter adjusts his cap as he talks with reporters prior to the Yanke …

The sold-out crowd, peppered with fans in pinstriped No. 2 jerseys, chanted Jeter's name in the second inning - something that would not have been tolerated a decade ago, when Bostonians wore profane T-shirts about Jeter and argued that Nomar Garciaparra was a better shortstop.
Since then, though, the Red Sox have ended their eight-decade World Series drought - winning three titles in 10 years, in fact - and the rivalry has lost some of its edge.
''I think after they won - I don't want to say they softened up, I would say I think they're kinder,'' said Jeter, who ventured onto the streets of Boston for lunch on Friday afternoon and was greeted warmly. ''People were saying, 'Congratulations for the career. I'm a Red Sox fan and I hate the Yankees, but I respect you.'
''Even when I was walking here through the stands, people were cheering. I remember in 1999, when I was here for the All-Star Game ... I remember getting out of the car and I thought they were going to kill me. Funny how things have changed.''
And the feeling is mutual.
View gallery

New York Yankees' Derek Jeter (2) is mobbed by teammates after driving in the winning run with a …

Although his night off no doubt disappointed those who bought a ticket for an otherwise meaningless game hoping to see a part of history, Jeter said he would play the final two games of the season out of respect for the rivalry.
''It's always difficult at this point because everybody wants to see him,'' Girardi said. ''I think Derek understands the magnitude of the rivalry and the importance of it in the game of baseball. ... I think there's a huge amount of respect too for what these organizations have done for the game of baseball.''
Red Sox manager John Farrell said Jeter's Yankee Stadium finale was special, and he expects the good feelings to surround this weekend, too.
''The game has an incredible way of creating unique opportunities,'' Farrell said. ''His 3,000th hit is a solo home run, his last at-bat at Yankee Stadium is a walk-off. The game provides us opportunities that embed memories, and that's certainly one of them.''
Elsewhere in baseball, they were also talking about Jeter.
''When you look at great players, you look at them as the heat turns up, they get calm,'' Washington Nationals manager Matt Williams said. ''Not everybody can do that. But he's one of them that can. ... That's why he got the hit last night. Because the situation is never too big for him.''

You're right.......he's a pussy.

We can all read between the lines. He should have played tonight. There are NYY fans up here who bought tickets to this game months ago. Jeter screwed those Italians.......
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,109,541
Messages
13,460,646
Members
99,480
Latest member
viact
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com