So Luck is a Top 5 NFL QB...

[REDEYE]

Have you ever watched a colts game? I mean sit and watch this guy play qb? You do understand the colts got the 1st pick in the draft after having 1 or 2 wins and drafted luck...have virtually no improvements at any position and he's made the playoffs and afc champiomships with that same slop. If hilton and fleener didn't drop every other pass, he would be even better. The guy passes the eye test in every way for greatness...and when the colts add weapons....he will be even better.

If the nfl put every player in a draft right now...I think every gm would draft Luck #1 or #2

Not saying he shouldn't have been the top pick in the draft or that he is not a very good player...but he hasn't done anything great yet..carrying a team that some suggest doesn't make him great..he is very good at this point in his career

 

[The Guesser]

luck is a great qb, but until he win the sp, he will be just another dan marino

That's not too bad, having your career compared to the Great Dan Marino.

 

[REDEYE]

Have you ever watched a colts game? I mean sit and watch this guy play qb? You do understand the colts got the 1st pick in the draft after having 1 or 2 wins and drafted luck...have virtually no improvements at any position and he's made the playoffs and afc champiomships with that same slop. If hilton and fleener didn't drop every other pass, he would be even better. The guy passes the eye test in every way for greatness...and when the colts add weapons....he will be even better.

If the nfl put every player in a draft right now...I think every gm would draft Luck #1 or #2

You might be watching to many Colt games to make a sound judgement

 

[vitterd]

Not saying he shouldn't have been the top pick in the draft or that he is not a very good player...but he hasn't done anything great yet..carrying a team that some suggest doesn't make him great..he is very good at this point in his career

He's a top 5 qb in the nfl. He takes a 2 win team without him to playoffs in all 3 years he's in the league and one afc title game. Just because he can't beat the greatest qb of all time doesn't mean he isn't great.

 

[vitterd]

Not saying he shouldn't have been the top pick in the draft or that he is not a very good player...but he hasn't done anything great yet..carrying a team that some suggest doesn't make him great..he is very good at this point in his career

He's a top 5 qb in the nfl. He takes a 2 win team without him to playoffs in all 3 years he's in the league and one afc title game. Just because he can't beat the greatest qb of all time doesn't mean he isn't great.

 

[REDEYE]

He's a top 5 qb in the nfl. He takes a 2 win team without him to playoffs in all 3 years he's in the league and one afc title game. Just because he can't beat the greatest qb of all time doesn't mean he isn't great.

doesn't mean he is either...he has more help then you want to let on

 

[Shub]

He's a top 5 qb in the nfl. He takes a 2 win team without him to playoffs in all 3 years he's in the league and one afc title game. Just because he can't beat the greatest qb of all time doesn't mean he isn't great.

2 win team. I love that one.

 

[vitterd]

doesn't mean he is either...he has more help then you want to let on

Let me know what that help is. His line can't block, his recievers can't catch and hiis defense can't stop a runny nose.

 

[vitterd]

2 win team. I love that one.

How many wins did they have the year before they drafted him? Talent wise...it is the same team that year

 

[vitterd]

2 win team. I love that one.

How many wins did they have the year before they drafted him? Talent wise...it is the same team that year

 

[doubledeuce22]

To act like that was a real 2 win team is a joke. Indy totally tanked that year, basically losing on purpose and signing a qb a week before season started. If another team tanked like that league pundits would be screaming bloody murder.

 

[FairWarning]

I want to see a list of five QB's that are better than him right now.

 

[REDEYE]

still haven't seen a post yet on what he has done that's great.... we can debate 5 pages on this thread on how good Luck's roster is but that's not going to decide whether he is great or not.... Can he be ? sure he can.....but not yet homers

 

[vitterd]

still haven't seen a post yet on what he has done that's great.... we can debate 5 pages on this thread on how good Luck's roster is but that's not going to decide whether he is great or not.... Can he be ? sure he can.....but not yet homers

You don't think tha taking a terrible team to playoffs and afc championship in his 1st three years great? Considering if you take him off that team...they are a pk or underdogs against the jags.

 

[REDEYE]

You don't think tha taking a terrible team to playoffs and afc championship in his 1st three years great? Considering if you take him off that team...they are a pk or underdogs against the jags.

No I don't

 

[doubledeuce22]

You don't think tha taking a terrible team to playoffs and afc championship in his 1st three years great? Considering if you take him off that team...they are a pk or underdogs against the jags.

That division stinks.. And they won a home game vs the bengals. When's the parade?

 

[vitterd]

That division stinks.. And they won a home game vs the bengals. When's the parade?

Who is asking for a parade? How many great qb' have their been? My goodness, elway got blown out in playoffs and super bowls for a decade and many still comsidered great. Dan Marino ring a bell. Might not wanna get caught up in just super bowl wins....trent dilfer has 1 and marino has 0. And we all know every gm would take Luck 1 or 2 right now if the nfl held a draft.

 

[vitterd]

No I don't

Well then I can't say anything. Once he wins a super bowl we can put him up there with the great onses like trent dilfer and brad johnson

 

[vitterd]

That division stinks.. And they won a home game vs the bengals. When's the parade?

And denver on the road....and kc last year after their defense made alex amith look like andrew luck for 3 quarters

 

[MantisToboggan]

And denver on the road....and kc last year after their defense made alex amith look like andrew luck for 3 quarters

He hasn't been anything special in the playoffs as a whole. Even in your KC game he threw 3 INTs. He's a solid QB but he's still a guy who owns a QB ratings of 70.8 in the playoffs with 9 TDs vs 12 INTs and a 56% completion percentage.