Totally ignorant reply. You guess Cain is good too? He's still only 24 (younger than Lincecum) and has a 3.74 ERA with a 1.28 WHIP over 654+ big league innings--if he pitched anywhere else (except maybe SD, Pitt, or Was), he'd be heralded as a stud. What about Sanchez, Johnson, and Zito at #5?
Easily the best rotation in the West, maybe in the NL.
Totally ignorant reply.
If he pitched anywhere else he'd be labeled a stud? The guy pitches in a pitchers park against the weakest hitting division in baseball. He's obviously an above average starter and a very nice #2 (who I complimented in a recent thread) but the guy still has work to do. He's a flyball pitcher who has most of his games in some of the biggest parks in the league... That helps his stats a ton. He has a great ceiling but still has command issues and his pitch counts are always high. He's a slightly above average #2 at this stage.
Randy Johnson can barely hit 92 on his fastball anymore. His slider is way down too plus he can't go deep in games. The guy is on his way out.
Sanchez is a guy who has upside for sure but he reminds me a little of Daniel Cabrera. Nice stuff and all but it's not worth crap if you can't control where it's going. Another guy with mechanical issues who had a 5+ ERA last season.
As for Zito... come on, seriously? His ERA was 5.15 last year. His stuff wasn't there last year and he's at a very old age for mechanical issues to be a problem.
You are excited about that? It's Lincecum and Cain and then guys with tons of issues.
That's not even taking into account the offense whose big signing was Edgar Renteria who lost 52 points on his average last year. Rowand can't hit HRs now that he's left Philly and for them to score runs this year, Sandoval better be all he's hailed to be.
Their #3-#5 pitchers are not going to go deep into games and that leaves the Giants with a closer who had an ERA at 4.62 who only has one freakin pitch that's any good. Their big relief signing was Bobby Howry and his 5.35 ERA last year and looks to be on his way out. Taschner might be 3rd on the relief depth chart and the guy had an 8.38 ERA last season. Are these the guys you want to count on since your starters don't go deep?
And that about sums up how ignorant my reply was. :toast: