Want to settle a bet here.
FairWarning Official Rx music critic and beer snob Joined Jun 21, 2003 Messages 25,128 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #1 Want to settle a bet here.
MIKEY.1TIME BEER DRINKER Joined Dec 20, 2005 Messages 3,030 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #2 heres one steve carlton
Gravy Member Joined Oct 22, 2004 Messages 17,006 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #3 No particular order Nolan Ryan Jim Palmer Steve Carlton Gaylord Perry Tom Seaver Catfish Hunter
whalewager AIG Bonus Recipient Joined Feb 15, 2006 Messages 17,848 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #4 Carlton Ryan Seaver Gibson Palmer
ProPokerPlayer I'll be in the Bar..With my head on the Bar Joined Oct 3, 2004 Messages 9,980 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #5 Ron Guidry and Vida Blue were pretty good in the 70's....Not sure how all the other great ones stack up if you just use stats from the 70's And Sparky Lyle had some pretty big stats as well.........
Ron Guidry and Vida Blue were pretty good in the 70's....Not sure how all the other great ones stack up if you just use stats from the 70's And Sparky Lyle had some pretty big stats as well.........
JakeT. New member Joined Apr 21, 2002 Messages 28,149 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #6 whalewager said: Carlton Ryan Seaver Gibson Palmer Click to expand... Personally I wouldn't consider Gibson a 70s pitcher per say.
whalewager said: Carlton Ryan Seaver Gibson Palmer Click to expand... Personally I wouldn't consider Gibson a 70s pitcher per say.
JakeT. New member Joined Apr 21, 2002 Messages 28,149 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #7 Carlton, Seaver, and Palmer for sure. Nolan Ryan probably has to make it somewhere as well. Gaylord Perry possibly in the last spot?
Carlton, Seaver, and Palmer for sure. Nolan Ryan probably has to make it somewhere as well. Gaylord Perry possibly in the last spot?
whalewager AIG Bonus Recipient Joined Feb 15, 2006 Messages 17,848 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #8 if gibson pitched in only 1 game in the 70s he would be considered one of the best to me...he is probably the best ever along with Satchel
if gibson pitched in only 1 game in the 70s he would be considered one of the best to me...he is probably the best ever along with Satchel
whalewager AIG Bonus Recipient Joined Feb 15, 2006 Messages 17,848 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #9 Jake, you werent even born
FairWarning Official Rx music critic and beer snob Joined Jun 21, 2003 Messages 25,128 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #10 whalewager said: if gibson pitched in only 1 game in the 70s he would be considered one of the best to me...he is probably the best ever along with Satchel Click to expand... Keeping the white man down I see.
whalewager said: if gibson pitched in only 1 game in the 70s he would be considered one of the best to me...he is probably the best ever along with Satchel Click to expand... Keeping the white man down I see.
Mr_Mark Member Joined Aug 20, 2007 Messages 12,082 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #11 FairWarning said: Keeping the white man down I see. Click to expand... @)
billhill999 New member Joined Jun 2, 2006 Messages 29,253 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #12 Palmer, Perry, Seaver, Hunter, Sparky Lyle.
SSI New member Joined Sep 21, 2004 Messages 14,040 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #13 no doubt about: carlton seaver palmer u can then argue the rest.. catfish hunter nolan ryan gaylord perry dont know ferguson jenkins years right off hand..
no doubt about: carlton seaver palmer u can then argue the rest.. catfish hunter nolan ryan gaylord perry dont know ferguson jenkins years right off hand..
WorldNumberOne Self appointed RX World Champion Handicapper Joined Nov 20, 2001 Messages 15,052 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #14 dont need to mention the top 3 again. other in my opinion could be guidry tiant jenkins hunter sutton
dont need to mention the top 3 again. other in my opinion could be guidry tiant jenkins hunter sutton
Donnybasbl Undercover Spelling and Grammar Police Joined Sep 2, 2005 Messages 1,799 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #15 Seaver Palmer Carlton Perry Jenkins
quantumleap Oh boy! Joined Mar 21, 2004 Messages 38,373 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #16 whalewager said: if gibson pitched in only 1 game in the 70s he would be considered one of the best to me...he is probably the best ever along with Satchel Click to expand... Gibson was the best of the modern era.
whalewager said: if gibson pitched in only 1 game in the 70s he would be considered one of the best to me...he is probably the best ever along with Satchel Click to expand... Gibson was the best of the modern era.
GilRenard New member Joined Jan 21, 2005 Messages 1,559 Tokens Mar 25, 2009 #17 I'll bite... Palmer, Carlton, Seaver, Blue, and Perry
slapshot Member Joined Sep 21, 2004 Messages 19,479 Tokens Mar 26, 2009 #18 Palmer then Hunter Seaver Carlton Blue
TomGshotput Rx. Senior Joined Nov 8, 2007 Messages 5,490 Tokens Mar 26, 2009 #19 What kind of bet can be settled by the opinions of rx members? Or did you really bet on the opinions of the people here?
What kind of bet can be settled by the opinions of rx members? Or did you really bet on the opinions of the people here?
TheKinz Show me a good loser, and I'll show you a loser Joined Jun 22, 2005 Messages 3,127 Tokens Mar 26, 2009 #20 reliever....just had to post
