Betting Picks & Tips
Cincinnati at Pittsburgh (-130); Total: 7.5
The Reds and Pirates are the first game on the board with any betting interest, as the two afternoon games feature lopsided lines. It will be Luis Castillo against Gerrit Cole in this tilt, as the Reds look to get another start or two out of the promising 24-year-old. Barring a total disaster, Castillo will cross the 160-inning mark in this start for the first time in his career. He’s already set a new high in innings pitched with 157.2 innings of work. A lot of pitchers fall into this group at this point in the season, so we’re constantly looking for those spots where fatigue is a factor.
Given the recent performances for Castillo, that doesn’t seem to be the case. Castillo has a 3.26/3.98/3.65 pitcher slash in his 77.1 innings at the big league level. He’s allowed three runs in his last three starts and has 24 strikeouts in 17 innings of work. I don’t see anything to be worried about. We’re not seeing an increase in fly balls, a drop in command, or a drop in control. He looks fit as a fiddle right now, so he’s definitely a guy worthy of consideration.
Gerrit Cole seems to have pushed through a bit of a dead arm period for him. He has a 3.99 ERA with a 4.18 FIP and a 3.86 xFIP. He’s worked 167 innings this year after being limited to 124 innings last year. His K rate is up and his walk rate is down, which are both good developments, but his command profile has taken a significant hit this season. Cole had a 6.8 percent HR/FB% last season and had never had one higher than 9.4 percent before this season’s 16.3 percent. Prior to throwing seven shutout against the Reds last time out, Cole had allowed 15 runs over his previous four starts, including six home runs. The strikeout numbers were still there, though, so he seems healthy to me. It was just a matter of running into some command problems. With a guy that was limited last season after throwing 200 innings in 2015, Cole will want to finish as strong as possible. That means he won’t throw away any of these starts at the back end of the season.
I’m looking for a low-scoring game here. PNC Park has been playing smaller of late, but the weather is getting much cooler in the Rust Belt. Cole’s SLG% against is 42 points lower at home than it is on the road and he’s allowed just 10 of his 27 HR at PNC Park. He’s shaved 88 points off of his SLG% against in the second half, so he’s getting better in that regard.
Give me the under tonight.
Los Angeles at Texas (-110); Total: 10.5
You have to wonder if the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim get a little bit of a shot in the arm today in Texas. The Angels were one of the more active teams at the waiver deal by grabbing Justin Upton and Brandon Phillips. You have to give this team and this front office a lot of credit. For a while, this team has basically been Mike Trout and a collection of average or below average players. Andrelton Simmons’s offensive breakout has turned him into a superstar with his plus-plus defense. Beyond that, this was a team that needed help. The fact that the Angels are in the Wild Card race is surprising to me, but here they are and they got markedly better yesterday.
Now, they’ll face a hated rival in the Texas Rangers. Texas opened a -135 favorite at Bookmaker, a -115 favorite at Pinnacle, and the preferred side remains the Angels, who are road chalk at some books. Tyler Skaggs is up against Cole Hamels in this matchup.
I really like this spot for the Angels. Confidence is high in that clubhouse right now. They endured a Mike Trout DL stint to stay afloat and are now right in the thick of the postseason chase. They’ve added at the waiver deadline with what could end up being a significant financial commitment if Justin Upton decides not to opt out. I’m not a huge Mike Scioscia fan because I’m not an old school guy, but Scioscia tends to have the respect of his players, so things are going well in that regard. I also like Skaggs. The southpaw has made 10 starts at the MLB level this season with a 4.25/4.17/4.24 pitcher slash. He’s coming back from Tommy John, which is no easy task and he’s never really been healthy for prolonged periods of time throughout his career. I am buying his upside. I’m a bit concerned about the lack of strikeouts in his recent starts, but I think the command profile is decent and he’s done a pretty good job of limiting walks.
The Rangers rank 19th in wOBA against LHP with a .313 mark and have an 89 wRC+ with a very friendly park factor at home, so their numbers are not great in this split.
Cole Hamels has a 3.78 ERA with a 4.68 FIP and a 4.89 xFIP on the season. The Angels got much, much better against lefties yesterday. We’ll see if Brandon Phillips is able to make it, but Justin Upton has a .477 wOBA in 117 PA against southpaws this season. This is an Angels team that was dead last in wOBA against lefties at .285. Phillips hasn’t shown much power against lefties, but he puts a lot of balls in play and has a .303 batting average in that split.
I’m not a big believer in the new Cole Hamels, who can’t strike anybody out. Hamels has just 67 strikeouts in 109.2 innings of work. He’s been very fortunate with a .240 BABIP against. That has started to turn a little bit in recent outings with nine hits allowed in 4.1 against Oakland and eight hits allowed in six against the Tigers. There’s very little to like about this BABIP-dependent profile.
I’ll take the Angels tonight. This is a rejuvenated team and the Rangers return home with a lot of other things taking away their focus.
Washington at Milwaukee (-140); Total: 9
A pretty significant line movement is the story in the Washington vs. Milwaukee game, as Jimmy Nelson and the host Brewers have been pumped up about 30 cents in the market from the Bookmaker open. Pinnacle opened closer to where the number currently is. The market really does not like Tanner Roark. Roark is my boy, but I’ve been wrong about him this season, to say the least.
It isn’t entirely my fault, though. Roark owns a 65.6 percent LOB%, which is among the lowest LOB% marks for qualified pitchers. He has a 4.63 ERA with a 4.21 FIP and a 4.28 xFIP as a result. All of his other peripherals fall into the average range, but his LOB% does not and he hasn’t been able to get out of enough jams to see some positive regression in that metric. Quietly, though, Roark hasn’t allowed more than three runs in any of his last five starts and that’s enough to give the Nationals and their strong offense a chance. In fact, Roark has only allowed more than three runs once since June 25. He’s actually 5-3 in that span, though win-loss record means nothing. It’s just a sign that his team has been a decent bet in his starts as the Nats are 6-3 in those nine starts. He has a 3.79 ERA with a 4.06 FIP and a 4.13 xFIP over his last nine starts and one relief appearance. I don’t think people realize how he has improved, even with a LOB% still below 69 percent in that span.
Jimmy Nelson shows some signs of positive regression, hence the line move. He has a 3.75 ERA with a 3.11 FIP and a 3.17 xFIP. Nelson is having a career year from a strikeout standpoint with 181 in 163.1 innings of work. He’s also induced a few more ground balls this season. There’s a lot to like about this profile, especially because he’s cut his walk rate by 4.4 percent this season. He’s allowed 10 runs over his last 18 innings of work and that comes on the heels of allowing 10 runs in 3.2 innings to Cincinnati on August 11. It’s possible that he may be starting to wear down a little bit, though the strikeout numbers are still there. The command is waning a bit.
I think I’m looking to take a shot with the road team here. Roark is an undervalued commodity right now as far as I’m concerned and the Nationals rank third in baseball in wOBA against RHP, so this is a tough matchup for any right-hander.
Kansas City (-115) at Minnesota; Total: 9
A huge series kicks off in the Twin Cities with a pitching matchup that makes you wonder how these two teams are in contention for a playoff spot. Jason Hammel will go for the Royals and Dillon Gee will go for the Twins. Hammel has been the sharp side in this one with a 4.76 ERA, a 4.48 FIP, and a 5.00 xFIP on the year in 149.1 innings of work.
Nobody seems interested to back Dillon Gee, who has a 3.53 ERA in three starts and seven relief outings, but he also has a 4.95 FIP and a 4.66 xFIP. He has allowed seven home runs in just 35.2 innings of work. Gee made one spot start for Texas back on June 6 and has made back-to-back starts for the Twins, with five runs allowed on nine hits in 10 innings of work. He does have a 9/1 K/BB ratio, so that’s solid.
This one of those matchups I don’t like to wager on. I’m basically betting on which guy will suck less and a lot of that ends up being BABIP-dependent. I understand the move, given that Hammel is a bit more proven and we can project his performance with a little more confidence than Gee, but I’m not interested.
Arizona (-110) at Colorado; Total: 12
Taijuan Walker has taken on a little bit of money for this one, as the Diamondbacks visit Coors Field. Kyle Freeland will be on the other side for Colorado, hence the move, since he is a guy that the advanced metrics do not think highly of at all. Walker does show some modest signs of regression with a 3.55 ERA, a 4.14 FIP, and a 4.44 xFIP, so I’m a little bit surprised to see the market taking a position on him at Coors Field.
Walker is having a fine season, but he has allowed 10 of his 15 home runs over his last 50.1 innings of work. He has a 3.93 ERA with a 5.12 FIP and a 4.64 xFIP in that span. His 76.9 percent LOB% has spared him further damage. He has a higher batting average against and a higher OBP against on the road, but has a 3.03 ERA compared to a 4.11 ERA at home, with a SLG% difference of 24 points. It’s simply a LOB% thing and a BABIP thing. His road BABIP is more normal than his home BABIP, so I’d actually be looking for some home regression at some point. I’m not thrilled with the idea of backing Walker here.
Kyle Freeland has a 3.81 ERA with a 4.66 FIP and a 4.64 xFIP on the season, so I can see why the markets aren’t buying his stock. He’s an extreme ground ball guy with a knack for inducing weak ground ball contact. That’s why he’s been able to carry a .291 BABIP against and a 77.6 percent LOB%. He’s mixed in a few more strikeouts as the season has gone along, but his BABIP has steadily rose. Still, he keeps his team in games and that’s all you can ask for at Coors Field.
The Diamondbacks are fourth in wOBA against righties, but 22nd in wOBA against lefties. I think there’s a smoke and mirrors element about this offense and you can see that in the season-long splits with RISP, where the Diamondbacks still have a .311 BABIP. They were leading the league for a while, but have regressed over the last couple of months.
I know Arizona is and has been the better team this season, but there are some factors that have me leaning towards the Rockies. Not the least of which is that the Diamondbacks just swept the Dodgers. They’re up 3.5 on the Rockies in the NL Wild Card. There’s a little bit of a “fat and happy” sense with this team coming into this series I believe. The Rockies are only 2.5 up on the Brewers, so desperation is setting in a little bit. I think their backs are far closer to the wall than the Diamondbacks, so I’m looking to buy the Rockies tonight and in this series.
Oakland at Seattle (-115); Total: 9.5
I’m taking the A’s tonight. I was a bit surprised to see that American League teams were interested in Mike Leake and the money remaining on that contract. Leake, who has never pitched in the AL, has a 4.21 ERA with a 4.21 FIP and a 4.00 xFIP this season. He’s very reliant on BABIP-luck and has carried some good LOB% in his career at times. Over the last two seasons, he hasn’t. Health has been a factor, as Leake had a battle with shingles last year that zapped some of his strength.
To me, this move looks a lot like the Tigers signing Jordan Zimmermann. It’s a profile that can work in the NL, where the pitcher hits and there are more elements of small ball and things of that sort. I don’t think it will translate to the American League as well. Leake has a 15.8 percent K%. If we sort qualified AL pitchers by lowest K%, we see Andrew Cashner, who is luckboxing his way to a 3.30 ERA with a 4.40 FIP and a 5.21 xFIP. Martin Perez has a 14.2 percent K% and a 4.89 ERA. Miguel Gonzalez has a 4.31/4.56/5.55 slash with a 14.5 percent K%. Jordan Zmmermann has a 6.08 ERA. Alex Cobb, Michael Fulmer, and Jason Vargas are the only ones with an ERA under 4.00 among the 12 lowest K% pitchers in the AL. I don’t see it as a sustainable profile for the Junior Circuit. I think Leake is in for a rude awakening. Also, for a pitcher that has openly talked about having a hard time maintaining his strength between starts, a trade to the Pacific Northwest this late in the year that uproots his family and puts a strain on his body clock is not a great move in my mind.
I like Sean Manaea a lot. He has struggled, with a 4.55/4.10/4.46 pitcher slash. The A’s are awful. But look at the line on this game. That should tell you what you need to know about how Leake is rated as an AL pitcher.
I’m on the visitors today.
St. Louis (-110) at San Francisco; Total: 8.5
Jack Flaherty will make his Major League debut at AT&T Park on Friday night for the St. Louis Cardinals in the spot previously occupied by Mike Leake. The Giants will counter with Johnny Cueto.
Flaherty had a 2.74 ERA with a 4.10 FIP and a 4.07 xFIP in 15 starts at Triple-A. He had a 1.42/2.31/2.94 in 10 starts at Double-A. So, this is a kid that has been making a rapid rise up the ranks and is only 21 years old. On the season, he’s got a 147/35 K/BB ratio and he has allowed 12 home runs, with 10 of those coming in Triple-A. It’s an interesting profile to say the least, as a big right-hander that doesn’t have a lot of mileage on his arm. He was predominantly a third baseman in high school, but started pitching during his junior year. As a senior, he had a breakout season and that was that. He’s carried some impressive pop up rates in the minor leagues, so he either mixes pitches really well or has some rise to that fastball that makes guys hit the bottom of the ball. It seems like AT&T Park would be a good fit for Flaherty.
One of the most intriguing stories of the rest of the season was supposed to be Johnny Cueto. Cueto has an opt out in his contract, but he’s been limited to 115.2 innings this season and hasn’t pitched well. He has a 4.59 ERA with a 4.65 FIP and a 4.42 xFIP. HE won’t get $21M per on the open market, so he’s better off riding this thing out. It seemed like Cueto wanted to exercise that option, but forearm troubles and bad pitching haven’t helped his cause. The Giants are also an awful defensive team.
This will be Cueto’s first MLB start since July 14, so that’s usually a stay away or fade spot for me. I have no interest in backing pitchers that are coming off the DL. He made a rehab start on July 31 and they shut him down. He pitched at Triple-A and worked three scoreless on August 22, but then gave up eight runs on nine hits in 3.2 innings in a High-A start on August 27.
I understand the line move and I’ll be looking to back the Cardinals, even with the long trip west.