Does Penn st deserve to be in the playoffs?

[bookiereport]

Big 10 champ. What do you think?
1. Alabama
2. Clemson
3. Washington
4. ????

 

[tulah]

No

 

[RunLeeRun]

No.
Washington deserves to be in

I think he means instead of Ohio State. I say yes.

 

[tulah]

I think he means instead of Ohio State. I say yes.

right.

I typed the wrong team

 

[Soccerguru]

Alabama, Clemson, Washington, Penn State

 

[tulah]

I hope for chaos so the committee takes heat and they get forced to expand to 6 or 8 teams.
that would be sweet.

also does it even matter who gets in. Alabama will beat anyone by 14+.

 

[Albatross]

Penn st

Yes they do.

 

[Willie99]

Bama, Clemson, Ohio St all appear to be in

Michigan, Penn St & Washington are all in the mix



Truth is, maybe only Bama is an absolute mortal lock. You can find a flaw in everybody else, you can make an argument for or against all the other teams

Be a great year to have 8 teams in the playoffs, which I think is the perfect number

 

[SunDodger]

I think they did enough. Penn St. beat Ohio St. SU, and won the Big 10.
　
My Vote:
　
1. Alabama 13-0
2. Washington 12-1
3. Clemson 12-1
4. Penn St. 11-2
5. Ohio St. 11-1
　
　
　
But, I've never seen a team get more favoritism than Ohio St. They probably won't even drop from the #2 spot. ESPN will spend all night telling us why they are more deserving.

 

[WinOne]

I'd drop Ohio St. They did not win the B10 and looking at the PSU conference body of work, beating the top 3 teams from the B10 West (Wisky, Iowa, Minny) and splitting with Mich and Ohio St, they should get in. Drop Ohio St, go with Bama, Clemson, Wash, PSU

 

[EveryGamblersDream]

I understand they have 2 losses compared to one but how can you reward Ohio State for having 1 less loss when they not only failed to win their conference much less a division within it & lost to the team that actually won a division & overall conference title.

 

[tulah]

I think they did enough. Penn St. beat Ohio St. SU, and won the Big 10.
　
My Vote:
　
1. Alabama 13-0
2. Washington 12-1
3. Clemson 12-1
4. Penn St. 11-2
5. Ohio St. 11-1
　
　
　
But, I've never seen a team get more favoritism than Ohio St. They probably won't even drop from the #2 spot. ESPN will spend all night telling us why they are more deserving.

agreed. OSU gets all the love.
CHAOS:toast:

 

[WinOne]

I understand they have 2 losses compared to one but how can you reward Ohio State for having 1 less loss when they not only failed to win their conference much less a division within it & lost to the team that actually won a division & overall conference title.

It's time the Committee talks about the 13th data point. They killed TCU and Baylor a couple years back. Drop Ohio St now. And dont drop Washington. Despite their non conference schedule, they played 11 P5 teams (10 in conference + 1 non con).

 

[Bad_Cat]

They will not jump Michigan. Michigan embarrassed them this year.

 

[Bad_Cat]

Winning your conference does not matter. It's the 4 best teams and penn state is not one of them

 

[Bad_Cat]

If you had 8 teams there would be more chaos. Think about it. It will be Alabama, Ohio State, Clemson and Washington, period.

 

[RunLeeRun]

They will not jump Michigan. Michigan embarrassed them this year.

Mich lost 2 of 4 in november. PS won 9 straight. Mich ends up 6th.

 

[RunLeeRun]

Winning your conference does not matter. It's the 4 best teams and penn state is not one of them

All playoff teams have won conferences to date, no?

 

[cigar]

ohio st shouldve been eliminated tonight

 

[SunDodger]

ESPN is acting like Ohio St. is a lock, and Washington is on the bubble with Michigan and Penn St. That is corrupt bullshit.
　
No fucking way the Big 10 deserves two spots.
　
I have to turn the channel now, as listening to this will drive me crazy.