5 probably.
I like Kamara over Barkley though. Just a higher floor and also he can be handcuffed via Ingram (and Ingram is probably flex viable even when they're both healthy depending on roster sizes) If Barkley goes down, the Giants are just gonna rotate 2-3 clowns and it'll be a mess.
Also, Kamara floor is just a lot higher and I think sometimes people make the mistake of trying to win the league in rd 1 rather than just try to make a good pick. Barkley might be the next L Bell but at that pick valuation you're really banking on it that he is, especially given the Giants QB/OL situation.
I don't understand why everyone thinks this. There is almost no way Kamara get over 250 touches this year if Ingham is still involed and Barkley likely sees 350 touches plus. Besides that the chances that Kamara scores at the rate he did last year is almost impossible. He scored a TD basically once every 15 times he touched the ball last year. By contrast over the course of Le'Veon Bell's career he has scored 1 TD roughly every 37 times he touches the ball. Do people really believe that he is going to keep scoring TD's at that pace? Either he has to get way more touches or its almost certain he will score less TD's this year imo.