Would you rather have Warner or Favre next year ?

[WorldNumberOne]

personally i hope favre retires .

but i would take warner if i had to use one or the other .

 

[steaktartar]

given the two warner

 

[fhmesq44]

I would rather have Warner than all but about 4 guys.

 

[viking611]

if either want a pretty good shot at another superbowl title, they should both be calling a (612) number.

 

[KeithRichard]

Favre is a cancer. I wouldn't let him on my team even if he took no pay. Warner is a money player and appears to have some class at least.

 

[guitarjosh]

Warner. Give him a competent set of officials and he has 3 SB rings.

 

[JakeT.]

Warner for sure. More accurate and a better decision maker. The only problem is his health really.

 

[BostonBettor]

Warner, but if went to a team with so-so receivers and a bad o-line he'd be just as bad as Favre. Cardinals should really try and re sign the guy.

 

[kingbill]

I would rather have Fitz and Boldin than Coles and Cotchery regardless of the QB

 

[NickPappagiorgio]

Warner. Give him a competent set of officials and he has 3 SB rings.

The first SB loss wasnt the officials fault. He needed an Offensive Coordinator that day that could adjust. Faulk was getting 5+ yds per run but Martz still wanted to throw the ball.

To answer the question, I would take Warner

 

[HacheMan]

One forces throws because he still believes his arm is what it was years ago, and the other can't hold onto the ball anytime someone touches him, so it's a tough call........:lolBIG:



Seriously though, I'd take Warner.....

 

[WorldNumberOne]

One forces throws because he still believes his arm is what it was years ago, and the other can't hold onto the ball anytime someone touches him, so it's a tough call........:lolBIG:



Seriously though, I'd take Warner.....

so let me get this straight... you disappear for a couple of years and then show up and start working out of the blue ????

 

[HacheMan]

so let me get this straight... you disappear for a couple of years and then show up and start working out of the blue ????

I wouldn't say I "disappeared" #1

Your name is one that has stuck with me though.........:toast:

 

[shiz]

warner by far. i think the jets players(majority) hopes farve goes bye-bye.

 

[WorldNumberOne]

I wouldn't say I "disappeared" #1

Your name is one that has stuck with me though.........:toast:

i do have a catchy name.... i am one original mofo...

 

[FairWarning]

Warner, but if went to a team with so-so receivers and a bad o-line he'd be just as bad as Favre. Cardinals should really try and re sign the guy.

Very true.

 

[HacheMan]

i do have a catchy name.... i am one original mofo...

Yes you do........

 

[JohnnyB]

Warner FTW.

 

[Betallsports]

Being a Jets fan, this is an Easy Question. Warner in a Heartbeat !

Umm, Can I have Fitzgerald Too ?? Hey ! I have to Dream, Right ? :lol:

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR]

Don't get jealous when the Eagles sign Boldin next year...