Who would you rather have on your team? Jimmy Graham or Calvin Johnson?

[blueedwardsII]

gronkowski might be better

 

[Dude]

In case you forgot Megatron had over 300 yards receiving last week. Brees throws the ball 40 times a game, compared to Chiefs QB's throwing 25 times a game when Gonzalez was there............

 

[Stylez]

C j

 

[doubledeuce22]

Kellen Winslow Sr, Russ Francis, Dave Casper, Jay Novacek, Mark Bavaro all better that Ive seen. Never saw Ditka, Mackey or Newsome. These guys all played in different systems, but because a TE puts up better numbers in a pass happy offense doesnt mean hes great

spot on

 

[PatsFan1283]

well lets just see if he can break all of gonzalez records,which i doubt very much as the way he is half crippled now he will never play long enough

lol peak J Graham owns peak TonyG be for real

answer is still calvin though

 

[PatsFan1283]

spot on

If you think Jay Novacek is better than J Graham your on crack....

 

[gynecologist]

If you think Jay Novacek is better than J Graham your on crack....

Some really good crack too.. Yeah WTF!??! Novacek better than Graham?

 

[CHOPTALK]

I expected most people to say CJ but some of you act like this is a ridiculous question.

Its a close call.

 

[Enfuego]

I expected most people to say CJ but some of you act like this is a ridiculous question.

Its a close call.

When 99 out of 100 would answer a A and B question one way, it's not a close call.

 

[CHOPTALK]

When 99 out of 100 would answer a A and B question one way, it's not a close call.

99 GM's would not answer CJ.
That was just someone's opinion about what 99 out of 100 GM's would say.

 

[CHOPTALK]

When 99 out of 100 would answer a A and B question one way, it's not a close call.

And there have been many times in the past where 99 out of 100 people have been wrong.

When 99 out of 100 people thought the Earth was flat for instance.

 

[Enfuego]

99 GM's would not answer CJ.
That was just someone's opinion about what 99 out of 100 GM's would say.

The NFL doesn't have 100 GMs but since you brought it up, 32 would say CJ.

 

[CHOPTALK]

The NFL doesn't have 100 GMs but since you brought it up, 32 would say CJ.

Not so.

 

[Enfuego]

Not so.

Well, if Matt Millen was still a GM, you'd be right.

 

[CHOPTALK]

Well, if Matt Millen was still a GM, you'd be right.

Matt Millen drafted CJ did you forget?

I know Sean Payton would not take CJ over JG

 

[gynecologist]

Well, if Matt Millen was still a GM, you'd be right.

Matt Millen actually drafted Calvin johnson.

 

[Enfuego]

Matt Millen drafted CJ did you forget?

I know Sean Payton would not take CJ over JG

But the GM would LOL.

 

[Enfuego]

Matt Millen actually drafted Calvin johnson.

You guys kind of missed my point.

I think MM was so bad, right now, he'd say "CJ is ok but I love JG going down the middle. I'd take Jimmy over CJ."

 

[CHOPTALK]

But the GM would LOL.

Sean Payton is the defacto GM of the Saints.
Saints draft who Payton wants.
Loomis keeps the cap in order and negotiates contracts.

 

[Enfuego]

Sean Payton is the defacto GM of the Saints.
Saints draft who Payton wants.
Loomis keeps the cap in order and negotiates contracts.

Are you being serious when you say Payton would take JG over CJ right now? Let's say Payton could have a serviceable TE to replace JG (not a superstar but a performer) and CJ you honestly think he'd still take JG?