Who should be the NFL Comeback Player of the Year ?

[Betallsports]

hmm

 

[Defying]

McClain

 

[Michelangelo]

Forsett

 

[The Guesser]

In order to be a comeback player, don't you have to have been good before? That kinda makes Forsett and McClain not qualified. Forsett's never been anything before, , and McClain was a draft bust who finally lived up to his draft status. I'd go with Foster, but any of the other 3 were great, were injured, and have come back from those injuries, and are worthy of the award, IMO.

 

[Vlad the Impaler]

I thought McClain was very good coming out of college....Goes to show you, Oakland is a place where everyone sucks.

 

[The Guesser]

I thought McClain was very good coming out of college....Goes to show you, Oakland is a place where everyone sucks.

Yeah, he was, but in the NFL he never did anything until this year.

 

[BAGIANT]

Phillip Rivers

 

[Willie99]

the SuperBowl MVP