Who is the most overrated QB of all time?

[AlistairCookie]

I'm drawing a blank.

 

[jacob]

ryan leaf

 

[AlistairCookie]

Oh ya, I remembered:

Here's a hint: He plays the game like a kid in a sandbox.

 

[BAGIANT]

Sonny Jurgenson!

 

[Cougfan]

Give me another hint and answer this: Do you have the Jets?

 

[OTK]

Although I agree Brett Favre is one of the most overrated QB's of all time since some people think he is the best (not in my top 10), but no way he is the absolute most overrated. Gotta be a few more overrated than him.

 

[dealerguy04]

brett farve is one of the best to ever put on the uniform period

 

[RedElephants]

Here's a list to help you out....

1. <LI value=1>Joe Montana <LI value=2>Dan Marino <LI value=3>Brett Favre <LI value=4>Bart Starr <LI value=5>Bob Griese <LI value=6>John Elway <LI value=7>Johnny Unitas <LI value=8>Peyton Manning <LI value=9>Roger Staubach <LI value=10>Joe Namath <LI value=11>Tom Brady <LI value=12>Fran Tarkenton <LI value=13>Terry Bradshaw <LI value=14>Phil Simms <LI value=15>Dan Fouts <LI value=16>Otto Graham <LI value=17>Troy Aikmen <LI value=18>Steve Young <LI value=19>Kurt Warner <LI value=20>Donovan McNabb <LI value=21>Daunte Culpepper <LI value=22>Jim Kelly <LI value=23>Warren Moon <LI value=24>Sammy Baugh <LI value=25>George Blanda <LI value=26>Len Dawson <LI value=27>Sonny Jurgensen <LI value=28>Bobby Layne <LI value=29>Y.A. Tittle <LI value=30>Jeff Hostetler <LI value=31>Norm Van Brocklin <LI value=32>Bob Waterfield <LI value=33>Michael Vick
2. Vinny Testeverde

 

[TopDawg24]

you guys are DELUSIONAL if you think favre is overrated

he's a legend

 

[AlistairCookie]

have the over...

But ya, Favre has screwed me before - most notably against Chicago last year with his stupid interception to Urlacher.

And it was hyperbole haha - he's not THE most overrated, but he's won as many superbowls as:

Mark Rypien
Jeff Hostetler
Doug Williams
Trent Dilfer

 

[AlistairCookie]

brett farve is one of the best to ever put on the uniform period

He wears Wranglers

 

[ksta7090ks]

ITS GOTTA BE:

MATT CASSELucking:

 

[dealerguy04]

whats your point

 

[pubguy]

that's your list of possible overrated QBs???

 

[TopDawg24]

Best QB ever

Matt Ryan

 

[Fearloathing]

Troy fucking Aikmen...had the best team EVER put around him and still tried to give games away on the regular.

 

[AlistairCookie]

whats your point

To paraphrase the great Louis Armstrong:

If you don't know already, I wouldn't be able to explain it to you.

 

[quantumleap]

What is Favre's record ATS for nationally televised games? I'm willing to bet it's very low and that's because the books adjust for Favre being overrated. More people will bet on him because they think he's good.

 

[pubguy]

Vick, Vince Young. Leaf was never rated just overhyped

 

[dealerguy04]

any black QB not named doug williams, warren moon, and ill give ya randall cunningham to