Who do the Denver Broncos Start at QB in the Playoffs ?? Osweiler or Manning ?

[Betallsports]

I want to say Manning ... only because he has the Experience

BUT, I really do think Manning is Done

 

[slapshot]

If Manning has been getting his medicine he probably starts if not Brock

 

[Willie99]

being a hater and proud, I want Manning

 

[wabashwonders]

I think if Manning is ready to play, you have to start him. But I'd keep him on a short leash.

 

[seldomseen]

Out of respect....Manning

 

[Michelangelo]

You mean the guy with 9 TDs and 17 interceptions. At least one pick in all 9 starts. 0 TDs in 4 of his starts. The guy who is 11-13 in the Playoffs.

If you want to win there can be only one starter. And his name is not Peyton.

 

[pocketrockets]

You mean the guy with 9 TDs and 17 interceptions. At least one pick in all 9 starts. 0 TDs in 4 of his starts. The guy who is 11-13 in the Playoffs.

If you want to win there can be only one starter. And his name is not Peyton.

+1.

Sad but true.

Seldomseen, out of respect is the worst reason ever, truth is, Payton should have respected himself enough to quit while he didn't suck... I'd say right after losing the SB against the chickenhawks.

 

[Enfuego]

You can't bench Manning. No way.

 

[texansfan]

You can't bench Manning. No way.

Why not? They guy has been horrible this season. Now Osweiler isn't all that good, but he's not turning the ball over like Manning did. I really don't believe it matters though, Denver is overrated imo and won't win in the playoffs regardless of who the QB is.

Manning is and always has been a regular season QB, a guy who piles up the stats but will never be known for winning when it counts.

 

[Vlad the Impaler]

Peyton is not going out this way. It just can not happen.

 

[SmokeyLa]

Who in the world would start Peyton? He was awful this year. Broncos benefited from a great defense and some luck or they would be 8-8 right now. The guy looks like he is throwing with his off hand.

 

[Vlad the Impaler]

Who in the world would start Peyton? He was awful this year. Broncos benefited from a great defense and some luck or they would be 8-8 right now. The guy looks like he is throwing with his off hand.

I'll take my chances

 

[TheComputerGroup]

I thought Manny was done, at least I thought I read that from ESPN

 

[Enfuego]

Why not? They guy has been horrible this season. Now Osweiler isn't all that good, but he's not turning the ball over like Manning did. I really don't believe it matters though, Denver is overrated imo and won't win in the playoffs regardless of who the QB is.

Manning is and always has been a regular season QB, a guy who piles up the stats but will never be known for winning when it counts.

Well, Kubiak is the problem but besides that, who gives you the better shot to win. Who scares you more? Assweiler or P. Manning?

 

[Mr_Mark]

no matter who they choose, if they loose, all the talk will be "they should have went with the other"

 

[Greenbacks]

Manning won`t see another snap this season.

 

[bounceback]

If he is healthy, his game management and football IQ in a do or die playoff game is most certainly +ev IMO vs starting Brock

 

[slapshot]

Manning the best system/game manager QB of all time is a back up today

 

[Vlad the Impaler]

Manning the best system/game manager QB of all time is a back up today

Manning was the system. Manning is the complete opposite of a system qb.

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR]

If at least 90 per cent healthy, I say Manning....