Which PLAYOFF QB would you want with the game on the line?

[Journeyman]

We have already seen a good bit of drama this post season, and I have a feeling we may see one more slobberknocker

Which of the remaining playoff QB's would you want on your team with the game on the line ?

As hot as Manning has been I would have to take him....His performance this post season just may go down in history, "IF" well you know the rest

 

[2times]

Brady without a question.

He already has a ring, and is just a WINNER!!!

 

[PanchoSanza]

Tom Brady, without question.

If this were 1984, Tom Brady is your Joe Montana, P Manning is your Dan Marino.

 

[Dante]

if we are not talking THIS year just overall ill take Rich gannon. He was the smartest QB in his hayday. I watched once about his work ethic he is an animal

 

[BoZZi]

Definitely Brady

 

[Seymour]

Donovan - no question - 351 total yards last game - we'll see how well Manning does this weekend.

 

[TheGeneral+]

 

[Journeyman]

Dante---"Gannon,in his heyday"

LOL- you act like Gannon has been retired for 10 years....It sure does seem hard to believe they were on top of the world just 365 days ago. Probably does seem longer to Gannon,lol.

 

[Journeyman]

If Manning lights up New England , I think this will shut all critics up forever that he can't win big games...I can see the door still slightly cracked open, as it was against Kansas City's defense...But he has been unreal the past two weeks...

 

[AAA15]

Thats a hard one. I am impressed with what Manning did in the playoffs so far. The thing about that is that he faced two weak Defenses in the games against Denver and the Chiefs. If he does it again against the Pats D, then no one can argue who the MAN is. For now I would take McNabb and Brady second. I just like the runnning factor of McNabb in tough situations.

 

[Dante]

<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by Journeyman:
Dante---"Gannon,in his heyday"

LOL- you act like Gannon has been retired for 10 years....It sure does seem hard to believe they were on top of the world just 365 days ago. Probably does seem longer to Gannon,lol.<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

I mean that he is over the hill and retiring soon...I used to watch him with the vikings way back...He was at his best 2 yrs ago IMO...

 

[TheGeneral+]

As a colt fan and watching every game, Manning has been on fire all season. When the team turns to him and forgets balance, he does his thing and has all year long. All of the comebacks this year were when the team turned to Peyton and said, "Ok, It's all you"

 

[MudSlideSlim]

Doug Williams

 

[RxScorekeeper]

Manning may be the games best student....Its really something when he plays mind games at the line of scrimmage inside of 5 sec's on the play clock....

Dante- I agree Gannon was awesome two years ago...I think that was his peak...He sucked at Minny,lol...

 

[Shick Quatro]

[This message was edited by Shick Quatro on January 16, 2004 at 05:03 PM.]

 

[raiders72001]

1. Brady
2. Manning

 

[1cheater]

Jim Kelly

 

[RPM]

definetly brady. just take a look at his numbers in the 4th quarter.

 

[KeithRichard]

Just for poise and smarts, Brady.May not be the most talented but what he showed iin the march to the Super Bowl proved he's a winner to me.