Which player is more dominant ?

[Betallsports]

:grandmais

 

[packer2012]

Kershaw..... case closed...... maybe an interesting, but not a serious question!

 

[Betallsports]

Kershaw..... case closed...... maybe an interesting, but not a serious question!

Maybe

 

[packer2012]

Hey Bet

Don't mean to overstep. I love Trout. He is everything baseball should be about. Just think right now Kershaw is clearly more dominant.

Trout's appearance on the scene really makes so many of these half-asses that people want to worship look sick. How big a joke is Puig? Mountains of talent, but dumb as a bag of hammers. Every time it looks like he might have things going the right way...... He steps on his nuts again. How about that little display a couple nights back against the Angels?

 

[Betallsports]

Not saying you are wrong...

 

[CHOPTALK]

Trout is the 2nd best position player I have ever seen.

I have seen at least 5 starting pitchers as good or better then Kershaw

 

[packer2012]

That's some pretty big britches to fill there Chop! (2nd best position player ever) You think you might be getting just a little ahead of yourself Sir?

I was answering the question posed ..... "Which player is more dominant ?"

Figured we were talking NOW and on days they are in the line-up.

 

[packer2012]

Would sure as heck be great to have either one on your team!

 

[CHOPTALK]

Greg M
Roger C
Pedro M
all 3 100% better then Kershaw

Barry Bonds only player I can say is 100% more dominant then Trout.

Bonds is the most dominant position player I have ever seen.
In a game of failure.
When you have someone who got on base 50% of the time thats incredible and will never be seen again.
When you intentionally walk someone with the bases loaded thats unreal.

 

[packer2012]

Totally agree on Bonds. ONLY weakness was average arm (but very accurate).

Surprised by your list of pitchers. Reposting my comment.......

"That's some pretty big britches to fill there Chop! (2nd best position player ever) You think you might be getting just a little ahead of yourself Sir?"

Are you saying pitchers you saw in person? I figured you were going back to Koufax and the like?

 

[packer2012]

Saw bonds live several times in different locations. Probably the greatest UMPIRE of all time. That while standing in the batter's box!

 

[CHOPTALK]

Would you put Kershaw above any of the 3 pitchers I just listed?

 

[packer2012]

I would just give him more time. I think with his power and stuff..... he has the chance to surpass some of them on his career.

 

[packer2012]

Chop, do you agree with me? .....

I have said before..... if they don't get Bonds and Rose in the Hall.... they should just burn the son-of-a-bitch down!

 

[CHOPTALK]

Yes I agree 100%

 

[Betallsports]

You guys can go back and forth all day. If the guy gets hurt today... The fight is lost.

 

[Shub]

kershaw can only be dominant every 5 days though.....

 

[PatsFanatic]

^ But Trout could go 4-4 in a game with 2 hr's and 5 RBI and they can still lose.

If Kershaw is dominate in a game they don't lose......ever

 

[Shub]

^ Or he could go 0-3 with a walk, 2 stolen bases, run and game ending assist.

 

[EzMoney012]

Kershaw