Where would you rate Jay Cutler among the current corp of NFL QB's

[zeeman]

CUTLER..................

Average backup

Very surprised you feel this way. So average backup means not in the top ten, probably not in the top 15?

I like to see how well Strafford, Bees, Ryan, Romo, Hasselback would be at the helm of the Bears offense. Strafford has Calvin Johnson, he's thrown a lot of interceptions. Now way he's better than Cutler! I don't think any of the above QB's would fare as well as Cutler.

 

[Stylez]

Yeah I forgot about Peyton. I totally disagree with you rating Stafford and Ryan ahead of Culter. What has Stafford done. But thanks for an honest response.

You curious where Seymour is. I believe he's hiding behind his computer. Seymour and Steak you both be sorry if you made that joke to my face. I look forward to meeting both of you in the near future.

After another season , Id still take Stafford and Ryan , along with luck now as well

 

[The Great One returns]

Stafford and Cutler are basically the same quarterback although I would take Stafford by a hair.

Cutler may be a top 3 quarterback.............................in the NFC North.

 

[Fishhead]

Stafford and Cutler are basically the same quarterback although I would take Stafford by a hair.

Cutler may be a top 3 quarterback.............................in the NFC North.

Yes, both big time losers and head cases.

 

[zeeman]

Yes, both big time losers and head cases.

It's quite obvious Cutler is better than Strafford.


Lets see, Andy Daulton didn't look to good on Saturday. He overthrew a wide open Green in the end zone with about 3 minutes left. May have been game winner. Most QB's complete this pass.

Andrew Luck didn't look to good yesterday against the Ravens. Luck has a ton of upside. I think the inexperience and being a rookie got to him at times.

Russell Wilson is looking great. He should be rookie of the year over Luck and Griffin.

Griffin had a great season, but all the hits he takes caught up to him. Would rather have Griffin than Newton.

Matt Schaub doesn't impress me. I'd take Culter over Schaub!

P.S.
Anybody think Ponder is a pussy? Misses a playoff game Saturday night because of an arm injury. I don't but I'm sure many do.

 

[JustinCruise]

He ranks somewhere in the bottom ten. I think Stafford is much better.

 

[zeeman]

He ranks somewhere in the bottom ten. I think Stafford is much better.

Much better? He sure didn't prove it this year. Lost to the Bears twice. Hasn't ever beated the Packers, pretty sure he has a terrible record against the Bears. In my eyes Stafford is way overrated. Probably the most overrated QB in the NFL.

 

[FairWarning]

There is a group that includes Stafford, Rivers, Cutler, Palmer that can win for you, but you need a lot more talent around them. I would rank them as high as 10 on a good day and 25 on a bad one. Lets say 15-20 overall.

 

[pocketrockets]

1.Manning
2.Rodgers
3.Brady

 

[The Great One returns]

1.Manning
2.Rodgers
3.Brady

Agree...Assuming Manning means Peyton. Greatest quarterback of all time

 

[5teamparlay]

Since the Bears O-Line has improved I really believe Culter is one of the best QB's out there. Definitely top 3 in my book.

Everybody who called him soft after he came out of last years Championship game against G.B. were wrong.

Barman, Please do your job. Thank You

LOL kth)(&^ointer: