Where does Arrieta rank among the all the time greats?

[JustinCruise]

Best ever?

Top 10?

Not even in the discussion?

 

[Willie99]

new kid on the block, not even in the discussion

and he may be the best in the game today

 

[wilbur]

He's the best in the last year

 

[5teamparlay]

64-38 in parts of 7 seasons


best ever. at least top 3.

 

[5teamparlay]

4.66
5.05
6.20
7.23

era first 4 with balto. disrespectively...

 

[HarryCaray]

Will be interesting to see what kind of numbers he can compile before free agency post-2017.

He needs to put together several more years like this to start being brought up on these lists.

What he did in the 2nd half of last year, spilling into this year, has been really special though. That is the type of 2nd half you see once every 50 years.

 

[doubledeuce22]

Arrieta > mlb testing

 

[doubledeuce22]

Guy is on a sick run no doubt.. Right now more similar to Fernando or hershiser than the all time greats. He is going to get PAID.

 

[AlwayzRight]

JC...insanely dumb to even start a thread like this. A 1.5 year wonder is not even close to the discussion. Period. Especially after being shit in Baltimore.

 

[JustinCruise]

JC...insanely dumb to even start a thread like this. A 1.5 year wonder is not even close to the discussion. Period. Especially after being shit in Baltimore.

Did I say he was in the discussion?:think2:

 

[AlwayzRight]

You started the thread "Where does Arrieta rank among the all time greats?". Again, insanely dumb and ignorant to even bring up the topic to even consider.

 

[CHOPTALK]

He's not even a hall of Famer yet. Not even close to a hall of Famer and you are asking if he is the best ever?

 

[5teamparlay]

all HOF pitcher then subtract 134


---

plus he will never win a ring with The cubs...

 

[JustinCruise]

You started the thread "Where does Arrieta rank among the all time greats?". Again, insanely dumb and ignorant to even bring up the topic to even consider.

I asked the question. I didn't provide any opinion on the matter.


If you think the thread is stupid feel free not to click on it


Instead, you decided to enter a thread you think is stupid, just to post that it's stupid. Then make ANOTHER post in said stupid thread.....smh

 

[pocketrockets]

He's not even a hall of Famer yet. Not even close to a hall of Famer and you are asking if he is the best ever?

i bet this thread is a lock, POY POY POY

 

[AlwayzRight]

I asked the question. I didn't provide any opinion on the matter.


If you think the thread is stupid feel free not to click on it


Instead, you decided to enter a thread you think is stupid, just to post that it's stupid. Then make ANOTHER post in said stupid thread.....smh

WHY EVEN ASK THE QUESTION IN THE FIRST PLACE? That is the real question. SMH

 

[JustinCruise]

WHY EVEN ASK THE QUESTION IN THE FIRST PLACE? That is the real question. SMH

You have now made 3 posts in a thread you think is a waste of time

 

[JustinCruise]

I tend to agree that he is a little overhyped. Someone is going to way overpay for this guy on his next contract. Already in his 30's too

 

[JudgeWapner]

He does it for another 10 years, he belongs with the all time greats.

 

[CHOPTALK]

Tommy John surgery in his near future due to this thread.
This is worse then the madden curse