Where do you Rank Michael Vick among Today's QB's ?

[Enfuego]

You realize that there are 7 colors in a rainbow? Notice how my post had nothing to do with this thread either?

If you can argue that Boise should play for the National Championship despite their horrible schedule then you can argue that M Vick is a top 5 QB in the NFL despite his opponents pass defense. They are one in the same.

 

[JakeT.]

If you can argue that Boise should play for the National Championship despite their horrible schedule then you can argue that M Vick is a top 5 QB in the NFL despite his opponents pass defense. They are one in the same.

I can argue that an orange is a Ferrari but don't feel strongly compelled to do so. Keep on track in this thread. It's not for your blue turf blues.

 

[soonerdawg1]

@)

 

[RobFunk]

I put top ten. The guy is an impact player STILL. Make no mistake about it.

Has a lot of speed and a decent arm. It's still pretty close to an offensive coordinator's wet dream, even now.

 

[Willie99]

I put him Top 5

 

[NoChipNo]

Ya hes top 5 THIS season but there are 7ish qbs I want running my team come playoff time and Vick is not one of them

 

[HiPockets]

This thread spins my head. QBs do lots- run, pass, call plays, lead teams, and then they run into defenses that are strong against what they do best or their team had to fly across the country and play the jet-lag dance. I vote 'none of the above'. Vick got over on the 32nd ranked defense on a cold rain night and now he should take his honorable place in the 'first half of the season' popemobile parade? Not. Sidenote- Vick played HS ball down in the tidewater area, and there is a team- Phoebus- from Hampton area that is worth watching (just starting the Va state playoffs).

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR]

I put him ahead of any 49er QB this year....

 

[JakeT.]

I put him ahead of any 49er QB this year....

Granted...