What team would win? The Jets with Peyton Manning or the Broncos with Geno Smith?

[CHOPTALK]

I think the Jets would beat the Broncos more often then not.

 

[Bourn]

I think you need to be focusing on your Saints. Almost game time Chop! Get your helmet on!! w-thumbs!^

 

[JustinCruise]

Jets.

This is a quarterback league

 

[PatsFan1283]

hmm I think the Jets would get it 6 out of 10

the Jets have 1 of the best run Ds in the league, a good defensive coach and actually do have some talent on offense. solid OL

yeah Jets likely

 

[Bourn]

Just noticed Saints have the late game. Should be a good one. Go Saints!!

 

[Akillies]

announcers trying to sell "Manning is surrounded by a great supporting cast" are dreaming
just look at eric decker and how well he is doing on the Jets with out peyton
broncos running backs mediocre at best, tight end average, demaris is an star the rest of the receivers are fill in replacement level
payton goes down and the broncos are the raiders

 

[PatsFan1283]

I dunno about all that but yes Peyton Manning is pretty good

 

[JakeT.]

Jets easily.

 

[PatsFan1283]

what about Broncos and Raiders

be a hell of a battle...probably go Broncos there

 

[FairWarning]

announcers trying to sell "Manning is surrounded by a great supporting cast" are dreaming
just look at eric decker and how well he is doing on the Jets with out peyton
broncos running backs mediocre at best, tight end average, demaris is an star the rest of the receivers are fill in replacement level
payton goes down and the broncos are the raiders

I would say the TE is top 3-5 with any decent QB.

 

[OneZero]

announcers trying to sell "Manning is surrounded by a great supporting cast" are dreaming
just look at eric decker and how well he is doing on the Jets with out peyton
broncos running backs mediocre at best, tight end average, demaris is an star the rest of the receivers are fill in replacement level
payton goes down and the broncos are the raiders

demaris thomas - top 5 WR
julius Thomas - top 3 TE - unstoppable in red zone
Wes welker - (still) best slot WR in the game

i agree with his RBs are mediocre. But no way close to being the raiders if manning goes down- much, much better.

 

[The Guesser]

Jets 8 out of 10.

 

[Akillies]

I would say the TE is top 3-5 with any decent QB.

raiders te is better than julius

 

[Akillies]

demaris thomas - top 5 WR
julius Thomas - top 3 TE - unstoppable in red zone
Wes welker - (still) best slot WR in the game

i agree with his RBs are mediocre. But no way close to being the raiders if manning goes down- much, much better.

welker, does he even play anymore

 

[shdw01]

I haven't watched enough jets to know the reality of my scenario. What I do know is that the Denver line gives Peyton enough time to do what he does (a lot is his pre-snap adj).....if the Jets can't block worth a dime, then Peyton will struggle.

and on the flip side, if Geno smith has all day for a change, and with his legs as another option, then it would be a much more effective result.

 

[doubledeuce22]

announcers trying to sell "Manning is surrounded by a great supporting cast" are dreaming
just look at eric decker and how well he is doing on the Jets with out peyton
broncos running backs mediocre at best, tight end average, demaris is an star the rest of the receivers are fill in replacement level
payton goes down and the broncos are the raiders

Are you on drugs?

 

[Acebb]

We’re not a bad football team,” Eric Decker of the Jets said afterward. “We just do stupid stuff.”

@)

 

[OneZero]

welker, does he even play anymore

Yes, with all of that great supporting cast on that team, many forget about Wes.

 

[Akillies]

put those guys on the jets and no one even knows their names

 

[Akillies]

put payton on the jets and you would be telling me their te was an all pro as well as Decker