What pitcher would you rather have?

[Timetopay]

Lets not google anything you bastards and just play along.

A. 3.34 era,1.14 whip,1700 k's,2 cy youngs,top 3 in era 3 times, 3 time allstar

B. 3.46 era,1.25 whip, 2668 k's,1 cy youngs,top 3 in era 4 years,5 time allstar

C.3.49 era,1.30 whip,2554 k's,2 cy youngs,top 3 in era 2 years,10 time allstar

D.3.28 era,1.22 whip,2397 k's,0 cy youngs, top 3 in era 4 years,6 time allstar

E.3.44 era,1.24 whip,1669 k's.0 cy youngs, top 3 in era 3 years, 7 time allstar

Set up your 5 man rotation if you were going to start a season with these 5...

 

[SkinsRaj28]

A. Seems like he's significantly younger than the majority of the other pitchers on that list, and also has a great ERA and WHIP. And if he's much younger than B-D, he's a good strikeout pitcher too.

Is that Roy Oswalt? Just a guess without Google...not sure if he's won the Cy Young once or twice, though. Or maybe it's Johan Santana.

 

[billhill999]

A. Seems like he's significantly younger than the majority of the other pitchers on that list, and also has a great ERA and WHIP. And if he's much younger than B-D, he's a good strikeout pitcher too.

Is that Roy Oswalt? Just a guess without Google...not sure if he's won the Cy Young once or twice, though. Or maybe it's Johan Santana.

Agreed.
A

 

[steaktartar]

i know c is glavine rest im getting

 

[Timetopay]

DIKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK.

Why you got to fuck up my first good post of of almost 3500?

 

[steaktartar]

DIKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK.

Why you got to fuck up my first good post of of almost 3500?

lol whats the point of the post if we arent supposed to guess who they are?......and u had 8 other quality posts so dont sell yourself short

 

[Timetopay]

:banger: Not sure the point of the post. Just woke up and had some pep in my step and was inspired to make a good post.

Just wanted to see not know who they were if you were going to set up a rotation how you would put these guys.

Guess away but u aint getting them...

 

[steaktartar]

ya im stumped after glavine anyway

 

[jeckll]

Lets not google anything you bastards and just play along.

A. 3.34 era,1.14 whip,1700 k's,2 cy youngs,top 3 in era 3 times, 3 time allstar

B. 3.46 era,1.25 whip, 2668 k's,1 cy youngs,top 3 in era 4 years,5 time allstar

C.3.49 era,1.30 whip,2554 k's,2 cy youngs,top 3 in era 2 years,10 time allstar

D.3.28 era,1.22 whip,2397 k's,0 cy youngs, top 3 in era 4 years,6 time allstar

E.3.44 era,1.24 whip,1669 k's.0 cy youngs, top 3 in era 3 years, 7 time allstar

Set up your 5 man rotation if you were going to start a season with these 5...

A/D/B/E/C

 

[Journeyman]

Depends on which league they've been pitching in too.

 

[WorldNumberOne]

why would i want to start a team with david cone or kevin brown...

they are really old...

 

[Timetopay]

a & e AL (mostly)

c - national

b & d mostly NL

 

[steaktartar]

i know A..............can i say it?

 

[steaktartar]

dabec for me

 

[Timetopay]

Go ahead. My attempt at a good post is not working.

I wonder after knowing who each is if anyone would change thier mind on what order to pitch them...

 

[steaktartar]

Go ahead. My attempt at a good post is not working.

I wonder after knowing who each is if anyone would change thier mind on what order to pitch them...

ya it would......saberhagen

 

[Antonioli]

ADBEC

Cy Young and All-stars means nothing to me, but to have a career Whip at 1.14 is just remarkable

great thread sponge.

 

[fhmesq44]

A/D/B/E/C

assuming all are in the same league, that would be my order as well. If some are AL and others NL, that would change things

 

[Antonioli]

Out of curiosity, what is their career BIPA and their postseason W-L ERA?

 

[jeckll]

Out of curiosity, what is their career BIPA and their postseason W-L ERA?

Who cares about BIPA? Totally luck based...I'd rather know about their G/F ratio, HR/9 and K/BB...that would allow us to make a definite ranking.