John,
I am on the other side of the fence in this business (ie. a player) and there are people out there who are interested in the perspective from this side also...in a raw, unedited, unscreened, and uncensored form which is unlike a lot of communication from the book's side.
I pointed out something very real about VIP that most players were probably unaware of. I don't need to be sitting in on board meetings to know how they manage their lines and on what basis they boot players. And for a player these are some pretty important considerations.
I think I'm doing a favor to the betting public by pointing out my observations. Surely no harm can be done since people can ignore it if they like.
As for what weight one should assign to the Rx consensus, well... there are a lot more than 6 people who have expressed their opinion on VIP in some form or another over the years here. And these are among the best and the brightest, including many industry insiders. I think it's safe to say that anybody in the business who ignores the Rx is not playing with a full deck.