Man this is sad. Since Barry Sanders, these are the winners:
1988-Barry Sanders, Oklahoma State, RB
1989-Andre Ware, Houston, QB
1990-Ty Detmer, Brigham Young, QB
1991-Desmond Howard, Michigan, WR
1992-Gino Torretta, Miami, QB
1993-Charlie Ward, Florida State, QB
1994-Rashaan Salaam, Colorado, RB
1995-Eddie George, Ohio St., TB
1996-Danny Wuerffel, Florida, QB
1997-Charles Woodson, Michigan, CB
1998-Ricky Williams, Texas, RB
1999-Ron Dayne, Wisconsin, RB
2000-Chris Weinke, Florida State, QB
2001-Eric Crouch, Nebraska, QB
2002-Carson Palmer, Southern California, QB
2003-Jason White, Oklahoma, QB
2004-Matt Leinart, Southern California, QB
Looking over how few of these guys made an impact in the NFL I may think if I am Reggie they might as well give it to Vince.