Winky,
I respect your opinion, but I have been using these two simple methods for years and had only one losing season with them. I don't bet every game with the +1.5, but I bet them far more than I bet the games on the ML. Say what you want about your theory, but can you honestly tell me that there are squares on this number??? Really, I don't think any squares bet these, none. Maybe once in a blue moon they parlay them, but just think about square thinking. I know quite a few very sharp hockey bettors that load up on these. I used to think like you, why risk 2-1 on anything, but after looking at from the angle of finding the spots where the squares aren't this became a strong part of my arsenal. Choose to do as you wish, but just remember the books aren't giving away bargains. If you really think these are such bad ideas, why not just bet the favorite and lay the -1.5 all the time? There must be some value in that if that is what you believe wouldn't you say???