Trade - Torry Holt for Chris Johnson?

[theDude24]

got offered Chris Johnson for Torry Holt...
tempting


but wondering if its worht it to buy Johnson at his high and sell Holt... who knows how Holt is going to do this here?

Thoughts?

 

[raiseany]

Depends on your team. I`m thinking Johnson will be a Willie Parker like last year. Lots of yards potentially but not a lot of tds.

 

[MattMillen+]

Yeah, Bulger can't even drop back before having defenders in his face.

 

[MightyGinseng]

I think Chris Johnson will be a big part of that offense. It depends on who you have at RB/WR currently

 

[TBMIDD]

depends on your team, do you have two other WR's you'd start above Holt? above Johnson?

 

[Mr_Mark]

just from initial thoughts i wouldnt give up holt for johnson even though rams offense isnt doing much

but like everyone else has said main factor is who else is on your team

 

[JakeT.]

Hard to say without seeing your whole team.

 

[theDude24]

here is my team - trade was offered after week 1 (holt bad, johnson good) - holt showed a little life this week.... guy is still offering it.... my WR corps might be weak if I trade him - and my RB corps WAS solid (even though who knows now with Grant and LT with some injuries)

<TABLE class="teamtable dragenabled notdragging" id=statTable0 style="MARGIN-LEFT: 10px; WIDTH: 954px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 10px" cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 border=0><TBODY><TR class="odd first draggable" id=yui-gen0><TD class="pos first">QB</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Kurt Warner
(Ari - QB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=4541><OPTION value=QB selected>QB</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>@Was</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
12:00 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">39%</TD><TD class=stat>558</TD><TD class=stat>4</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>-4</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">39.00</TD></TR><TR class="even draggable" id=yui-gen1><TD class="pos first">QB</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Aaron Rodgers
(GB - QB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=7200><OPTION value=QB selected>QB</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>Dal</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
7:15 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">49%</TD><TD class=stat>506</TD><TD class=stat>4</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>60</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class="pts last">45.00</TD></TR><TR class="odd draggable" id=yui-gen2><TD class="pos first">WR</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Terrell Owens
(Dal - WR)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=3664><OPTION value=WR selected>WR</OPTION><OPTION value=W/T>W/T</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>@GB</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
7:15 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">99%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>8</TD><TD class=stat>176</TD><TD class=stat>3</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">38.00</TD></TR><TR class="even draggable" id=yui-gen3><TD class="pos first">WR</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Greg Jennings
(GB - WR)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=7801><OPTION value=WR selected>WR</OPTION><OPTION value=W/T>W/T</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>Dal</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
7:15 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">90%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>11</TD><TD class=stat>258</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">30.50</TD></TR><TR class="odd draggable" id=yui-gen4><TD class="pos first">RB</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>LaDainian Tomlinson
(SD - RB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=5452><OPTION value=RB selected>RB</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>NYJ</TD><TD class=gametime>Mon
7:30 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">93%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>123</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>5</TD><TD class=stat>29</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">11.50</TD></TR><TR class="even draggable" id=yui-gen5><TD class="pos first">RB</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Clinton Portis
(Was - RB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=5937><OPTION value=RB selected>RB</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>Ari</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
12:00 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">90%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>180</TD><TD class=stat>2</TD><TD class=stat>2</TD><TD class=stat>3</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">24.00</TD></TR><TR class="odd draggable" id=yui-gen6><TD class="pos first">TE</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Tony Gonzalez
(KC - TE)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=3950><OPTION value=TE selected>TE</OPTION><OPTION value=W/T>W/T</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>@Atl</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
12:00 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">92%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>11</TD><TD class=stat>94</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">19.50</TD></TR><TR class="even draggable" id=yui-gen7><TD class="pos first">W/T</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>DeSean Jackson
(Phi - WR)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=8826><OPTION value=WR>WR</OPTION><OPTION value=W/T selected>W/T</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>Pit</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
3:15 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">42%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>12</TD><TD class=stat>216</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">27.00</TD></TR><TR class="odd draggable" id=yui-gen8><TD class="pos first">W/R</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Ryan Grant
(GB - RB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=7635><OPTION value=RB>RB</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R selected>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>Dal</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
7:15 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">71%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>112</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">7.00</TD></TR><TR class="even draggable bench" id=yui-gen9><TD class="pos first">BN</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Derek Anderson
(Cle - QB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=7389><OPTION value=QB>QB</OPTION><OPTION value=BN selected>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>@Bal</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
3:15 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">51%</TD><TD class=stat>280</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>2</TD><TD class=stat>30</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">13.00</TD></TR><TR class="odd draggable bench" id=yui-gen10><TD class="pos first">BN</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Torry Holt
(StL - WR)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=4654><OPTION value=WR>WR</OPTION><OPTION value=W/T>W/T</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN selected>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>@Sea</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
3:05 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">77%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>7</TD><TD class=stat>85</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">16.50</TD></TR><TR class="even draggable bench" id=yui-gen11><TD class="pos first">BN</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Laurence Maroney
(NE - RB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=7770><OPTION value=RB>RB</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN selected>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>Mia</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
12:00 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">58%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>67</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">4.00</TD></TR><TR class="odd draggable bench" id=yui-gen12><TD class="pos first">BN</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Kevin Smith
(Det - RB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=8841><OPTION value=RB>RB</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN selected>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>@SF</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
3:05 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">32%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>88</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>8</TD><TD class=stat>53</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">20.00</TD></TR><TR class="even draggable bench" id=yui-gen13><TD class="pos first">BN</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>JaMarcus Russell
(Oak - QB)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=8255><OPTION value=QB>QB</OPTION><OPTION value=BN selected>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>@Buf</TD><TD class=gametime>Sun
12:00 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">4%</TD><TD class=stat>235</TD><TD class=stat>2</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>10</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class="pts last">15.00</TD></TR><TR class="odd draggable bench" id=yui-gen14><TD class="pos first">BN</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>Vincent Jackson
(SD - WR)
</TD><TD class=edit><SELECT name=7237><OPTION value=WR>WR</OPTION><OPTION value=W/T>W/T</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN selected>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp>NYJ</TD><TD class=gametime>Mon
7:30 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide">28%</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>9</TD><TD class=stat>120</TD><TD class=stat>1</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class=stat>0</TD><TD class="pts last">21.50</TD></TR><TR class="even draggable bench" id=yui-gen15><TD class="pos first">BN</TD><TD class=dragicon style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)"> </TD><TD class=player style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">Darren Sproles
(SD - RB)
</TD><TD class=edit style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)"><SELECT name=7306><OPTION value=RB>RB</OPTION><OPTION value=W/R>W/R</OPTION><OPTION value=BN selected>BN</OPTION></SELECT></TD><TD class=opp style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">NYJ</TD><TD class=gametime style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">Mon
7:30 pm</TD><TD class="stat wide" style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">8%</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">0</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">0</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">0</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">56</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">0</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">2</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">72</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">1</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">1</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">0</TD><TD class=stat style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">0</TD><TD class="pts last" style="FILTER: alpha(opacity=100)">23.00</TD></TR><TR class=empty id=test0.07833233940473827 playerPosition="ALL" position="ALL" playerId="ALL"><TD class="pos first">BN</TD><TD class=dragicon> </TD><TD class=player>--empty--
</TD><TD class=edit> </TD><TD class=opp> </TD><TD class=gametime> </TD><TD class="stat wide">-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class=stat>-</TD><TD class="pts last">0</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>

 

[FairWarning]

I wouldn't do it because you are loaded at RB.

 

[JakeT.]

You are loaded at RB. No reason to do that since Johnson would just sit on your bench.

 

[Mr_Mark]

keep holt