Trade advice

asufan550 · Oct 30, 2008

MJD, Roy Williams, and Eddie Royal for Chris Johnson.
My starting RB's would then be LDT and MJD--Williams and Royal would go into the mix with Jennings, Breaston, Ocho, and Randle el depending on the week, etc. I'd probably drop one of the afore mentioned WR's (Randle el), and Rhodes.
I'm leaning towards no because of inconsistency, but it could be a potentially big haul for a 10th+ round pick (Johnson).
Thoughts?

JakeT. · Oct 30, 2008

Do it. Chris is nice but White still gets goal line work and Jones-Drew will have some nice weeks. Williams and Royal are very nice starter-quality WRs.

fhmesq44 · Oct 30, 2008

I wouldn't do it. Williams is adjusting to a new offense with a backup QB and will always be second option there, also has to adjust to Romo when he comes back and Royal only has 29 points in his last 6 games.

Jennings is a must start so you are really throwing Williams and Royal into the mix with guys that are comparable to them. Breaston has been coming on. You basically give yourself two more mediocre receivers to choose from and downgrade at RB.

Williams, even when he is playing well, is maddeningly inconsistent.

fhmesq44 · Oct 30, 2008

Ariz can't run and even with Boldin back, there are plenty of balls to go around for the three of them.

thesccrguy15 · Oct 30, 2008

I'd do it. As someone stated, LenWhale White gets all the goal line work. MJD is a solid starter, and IMO Roy Williams will have to make an impact to turn Dallas around, I don't think there will be a huge adjustment for Romo or Williams. Eddie Royal just seals the deal as a upgrade/spot starter for certain weeks now since he's cooled off along with Denvers offense. If it were me, I'd do it.