Top 5 quarterbacks in the NFL

[chach]

How is McNabb better? He might be better at the Flutie-style escapes and have a stronger arm, but that doesn't come close to making him a better QB. I ranked those guys based on having the same offense to work with. I honestly believe any guy on that list would have Manning-type numbers given Manning's supporting cast. Possibly not quite as high because Manning is the cherry-picking Luc Robitaille of the NFL.
More importantly, I ranked them based on their ability to deal with pressure in a BIG game. I wouldn't rank McNabb in the top 10 QB's in the league in such a situation. Great athlete, sure, but clueless under pressure. Enjoy the regular season McNabb, because you won't be enjoying the playoffs McNabb... and I'll be around to eat some philly cheese steak with your choice of toppings come January if I'm wrong.

 

[charleslanger]

If the main criteria is now under pressure, Larry Byrd is THE nonpareil-- & that would go for hustle too.

 

[SoCal]

koy detmer

 

[bosox1086]

Did somebody type "Larry Byrd"??? I think him, Magik Jonson and Michal Jordin are the best players ever.