The Top 6 Draft Busts over last 20 years.

Search

New member
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
75,154
Tokens
FWIW -- I found this list while reading ESPN.com just now. The author is actually someone called MJD a contributer to an ESPN blog that took me to a site called Shutdown Corner at Yahoo Sports.com.. Thought some would find it interesting...wil.

1. Andre Ware, No. 7 overall, 1990.
The Heisman trophy winner was drafted by the Detroit Lions, but only got four years to soak in the expert tutelage of head coach Wayne Fontes. He could never beat out Erik Kramer or Rodney Peete for a permanent starting job, and ended up with the Raiders, where he was also promptly cut. Ware then made the move to the Canadian League, where he was also quite terrible.

But he's doing just fine these days, working as a college football analyst for ESPN, and as part of the Houston Texans broadcast team.

2. Ryan Leaf, No. 2 overall, 1998.
After doing everything he could to hurt the Chargers short of burning down Qualcomm Stadium and stabbing Junior Seau in the neck, Leaf bounced around to a couple of other NFL teams, most notably the Cowboys, but never found any success.
After leaving the NFL, Leaf spent a while coaching at West Texas A&M (he worked as the quarterbacks coach, and as the head coach on the golf team), but resigned after he asked a player for a pain pill.
But the good news for Leaf is that he managed his draft money well, he married a Chargers cheerleader, and you'll be happy to know that he's still making time for fun.

3. Lawrence Phillips, No. 6 overall, 1996.
After stellar rookie and sophomore years in which he averaged 3.3 and 3.4 yards per carry, respectively (had Phillips been able to stick with football and progress at the same rate, he'd be getting ready to average 4.6 yards per carry this season!) Phillips bounced around to a couple of other NFL teams, NFL Europe, Arena Football and the Canadian League. His career ended when two CFL teams cut him because he was kind of a jerk.
What's he doing these days? A 10-year stretch in California state prison. I'll let Wikipedia sum up his post-football criminal career:
On August 21, 2005, Phillips was arrested for assault after allegedly driving a car into three teenagers, following a dispute with the teens during a pick-up football game in Los Angeles, California. At the time of the arrest, Phillips was wanted by the San Diego, California, police in connection with two alleged domestic abuse incidents involving a former girlfriend, who claimed that Phillips choked her to the point of unconsciousness during one of the incidents. In addition, the Los Angeles Police Department was seeking Phillips in connection with yet another, separate domestic abuse allegation that had occurred previously in Los Angeles.
In March, 2006, the Associated Press reported that Phillips had been ordered to stand trial on felony assault with a deadly weapon charges stemming from the August 21, 2005, incident. The assigned judge dismissed two counts of child abuse and one count of leaving the scene of an accident, but continued the trial on the more serious charges.
On October 10, 2006, Phillips was found guilty of seven counts of assault with a deadly weapon. On October 3, 2008, Phillips was sentenced to 10 years in a California state prison.

4. Blair Thomas, No. 2 overall, 1990.
It feels a little unfair to call Thomas a bust, because his career was largely derailed by injuries, but he didn't last long in the league, and only gave the Jets four years and 2,009 total rushing yards.
That wasn't his only contribution to football, though. Thomas was the running backs coach at Temple University, where he helped develop two NFL running backs, which is two more than Temple has any right producing. Jason McKie and Stacey Mack both benefited from Thomas's coaching.
Today, Thomas and former Eagles receiver Kenny Jackson own a small chain of sports bars named "Kokomo's." They have "deep fried stuff galore".

5. Ki-Jana Carter, No. 1 overall, 1995.
Ki-Jana beat out even Ryan Leaf as Charles Robinson's worst all-time first-round draft pick back in 2007. That's the top of the mountain for draft bustage, really.
Carter tore up his knee in his first preseason game as a rookie and was never the same. He managed to stick around the league for seven more years, despite mostly anemic numbers. He peaked with the Redskins in 2001, when he carried 63 times for 308 yards and a 4.9 yards per carry average. After that, though, he failed to gain 100 more yards in his career.
I was hoping to find out that Ki-Jana and Blair Thomas opened up a roller disco together in State College, but that's not the case. Carter lives in Miami, does a little local broadcasting and hosts a Monday Night Football event at a Casino.

6. Tim Couch, No. 1 overall, 1999.
As a number one overall draft pick that went to a team in Cleveland, you might call Tim Couch "the anti-LeBron." Couch did manage to start for five years in Cleveland, though he only won 22 games in those five years, and his quarterback rating never broke out of the 70s. It wasn't like he didn't bring anyone any joy, though. Former Steelers broadcaster Myron Cope loved to make fun of him.
Couch tried to latch on with several other teams after finally being let go by the Browns, but he never saw another down of NFL action. He's currently working as a Kentucky Wildcats football analyst for the Big Blue Sports Network, but his best move was marrying former Playboy Playmate Heather Kozar, so he's got that going for him. Which is nice.

Shutdown Corner..
 

hacheman@therx.com
Staff member
Joined
Jan 2, 2002
Messages
139,222
Tokens
Not really sure how they can list Ware at #1 over the others simply because of where he was drafted, ad 7th overall........
 

New member
Joined
Apr 14, 2009
Messages
1,618
Tokens
ryan leaf will always be my #1
 

Last night I drank enough to kill a small Asian fa
Joined
Jan 25, 2005
Messages
6,839
Tokens
Tough to call people who got hurt busts. Heath Shuler woulda fit just fine on the list, Rick Mirer too
 

New member
Joined
Jun 25, 2005
Messages
7,018
Tokens
Heath Shuler

Shuler was a first-round selection in the 1994 NFL Draft, taken by the Washington Redskins with the third overall pick.
 

New member
Joined
Jan 30, 2006
Messages
4,555
Tokens
Tony Mandarich was a cant miss lineman that never did amount to crap, maybe over 20 yrs ago but i think he was a #2 overall

where will Vince Young end up on this list 10 yrs from now?
 

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
2,361
Tokens
Don't forget about Charles Rogers, the #2 overall in 2003 from Michigan State who was sucked into that vortex in Detroit never to be heard from or seen again.
 

hacheman@therx.com
Staff member
Joined
Jan 2, 2002
Messages
139,222
Tokens
Don't forget about Charles Rogers, the #2 overall in 2003 from Michigan State who was sucked into that vortex in Detroit never to be heard from or seen again.



Wasn't he pretty good the 1st year though, and got hurt or something & never returned to form?
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
99,709
Tokens
Wasn't he pretty good the 1st year though, and got hurt or something & never returned to form?


<TABLE cellSpacing=0 cellPadding=0 width="100%" border=0><TBODY><TR class=yspsctbg align=middle><TD class=ysptblhdr align=left width="20%" colSpan=4 height=18>Recent Career</TD><TD class=yspwhitebg noWrap width=1 rowSpan=6><SPACER width="1" height="1" type="block"></TD><TD class=ysptblhdr colSpan=9>Receiving</TD><TD class=yspwhitebg noWrap width=1 rowSpan=6><SPACER width="1" height="1" type="block"></TD><TD class=ysptblhdr colSpan=6>Kickoff Returns</TD><TD class=yspwhitebg noWrap width=1 rowSpan=6><SPACER width="1" height="1" type="block"></TD><TD class=ysptblhdr colSpan=6>Punt Returns</TD><TD class=yspwhitebg noWrap width=1 rowSpan=6><SPACER width="1" height="1" type="block"></TD><TD class=ysptblhdr colSpan=3>Fumbles</TD></TR><TR class=ysptblthbody1 align=right height=16><TD class=yspdetailttl align=left> Year</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl align=left>Team</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl align=right>G</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Rec</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Yds</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Y/G</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Avg</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Lng</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>YAC</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>1stD</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>TD</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>KR</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Yds</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Avg</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Long</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>TD</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>PR</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Yds</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Avg</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Long</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>TD</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>Fum</TD><TD class=yspdetailttl>FumL</TD><TD> </TD></TR><TR class=ysprow1 align=right height=16><TD class=yspscores align=left> 2003</TD><TD class=yspscores align=left>Detroit</TD><TD class=yspscores align=right>5</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>22</TD><TD class=yspscores>243</TD><TD class=yspscores>48.6</TD><TD class=yspscores>11.0</TD><TD class=yspscores>33</TD><TD class=yspscores>1.7</TD><TD class=yspscores>13</TD><TD class=yspscores>3</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD></TR><TR class=ysprow2 align=right height=16><TD class=yspscores align=left> 2004</TD><TD class=yspscores align=left>Detroit</TD><TD class=yspscores align=right>1</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0.0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0.0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0.0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD></TR><TR class=ysprow1 align=right height=16><TD class=yspscores align=left> 2005</TD><TD class=yspscores align=left>Detroit</TD><TD class=yspscores align=right>9</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>14</TD><TD class=yspscores>197</TD><TD class=yspscores>21.9</TD><TD class=yspscores>14.1</TD><TD class=yspscores>35</TD><TD class=yspscores>4.5</TD><TD class=yspscores>11</TD><TD class=yspscores>1</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD></TR><TR class=ysprow2 align=right height=16><TD class=yspscores align=left colSpan=2> Career Totals (Full)</TD><TD class=yspscores>15</TD><TD class=yspscores> </TD><TD class=yspscores>36</TD><TD class=yspscores>440</TD><TD class=yspscores>29.3</TD><TD class=yspscores>12.2</TD><TD class=yspscores>35</TD><TD class=yspscores>2.8</TD><TD class=yspscores>24</TD><TD class=yspscores>4</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD> </TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD><TD class=yspscores>0</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
 

New member
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
1,559
Tokens
Rogers broke his collarbone twice in less than a year, then got lazy, fat and high during his second "rehab". Just another victim of the Lions curse.

By the way, no way Ware should be anywhere near the top of the list. Yes he was terrible, but he's not even the biggest bust among Lions QB's during this time period (Joey Harrington).

Leaf was the biggest draft blunder ever and should top this list hands down. Not only was he drafted 2nd, the Chargers gave up a boatload to trade for the pick.
 

www.youtubecom/hubbardsmusic
Joined
Aug 21, 2003
Messages
11,679
Tokens
Phillips has to be #1 on that list....believe he is serving 10-12 right now in Cali pen.
 

Rx .Junior
Joined
Apr 14, 2008
Messages
812
Tokens
Todd Morenavich (sp?) deserves to be on the list more than some of these other guys.

Also agree, Leaf is definitely #1. His level of sucktitude is quite extraordinary
 

RX Senior
Joined
Nov 7, 2004
Messages
901
Tokens
Not sure how you can call Ki-Jana Cater a bust, unlucky is more like it when you blow out your knee in your first pre-season game.......
 

Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2007
Messages
12,081
Tokens
Not really sure how they can list Ware at #1 over the others simply because of where he was drafted, ad 7th overall........

yea i agree

maybe it is because he had alot of expectations to do well and never lived up to them, but being #7 i dont think qualifies for as big of a bust as #2 overall pick and retiring 3 years later at the age of 26

Career stats
TD - 14 INT - 36
Yards = 3,666 (kinda creepy)
QB Rating = 50.0

Leaf #1 overall biggest bust imo
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,119,830
Messages
13,573,727
Members
100,877
Latest member
kiemt5385
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com