HinesWard86 said:CHOP, even if NO goes 14-2 this season....if Indy goes 16-0 then Dungy wins Coach of the Year, no question about it. Dungy has been the bridesmaid to the award twice and he will get as much sympathy as New Orleans and Payton because of the tragic death of his son. Also, once the Colts hit 10-0 don't you think all the media hype will come and most voters would be swayed? Also, think of the backlash. If Dungy goes 16-0 and doesn't get COY, I guarantee that there will be cries of racism from the media, even though Lovie Smith just won the award last year. If the Colts go 16-0, Dungy wins COY and it won't be close.
MrCleo said:CHOP, i don't know how much action you want on that bet but I would take it with you if interested. (we already have the comeback player of the year award which will most likely be a push). Dungy wins coach of the year i don't care how many N.O wins if Colts go undefeated
CHOPTALK said:I will bet you $500 bucks, that if the Saints finish at least 12-4, and INDY finishes 16-0, Peyton still wins COY.
If both of those records dont happen for both of those teams, its a no bet.
For instance, if the Colts go 16-0 and the Saints go 11-5 or less, no bet.
If the Colts go 15-1, and the saints go 13-3, no bet.
But if the Saints win at least 12, and the colts go 16-0, I bet you $500 that peyton wins COY.
DEAL?
HinesWard86 said:Absolutely. DEAL. According to those parameters I will definitely take that.
CHOPTALK said:How about straight up? I have Peyton, you have Dungy. PERIOD.
MrCleo said:No, I was posting in response to the bet if Colts finish 16-0 and Saints have whatever record. If the Colts finish 14-2 it would be basically identical to last year and Dungy didn't win it. the whole point is, as good of a job Payton is doing in New Orleans, he won't win it if Colts go undefeated.
MrCleo said:Rookie of the Year - Vince Young
Comeback Player of the Year - Chad Pennington
MVP - Tomlinson
I guess Saints fans are still waiting
uppy:
would be a big surprise, to me at least, if Peyton didn't get COY though