I have been to both several times. You can't go wrong with either. It depends on your personal preference. One is watch games with beaches and possibly Disney and other various themeparks nearby or watch games in a desert atmosphere. Both were fun. Oh fyi, there really isn't alot of humdity in Florida during April. The weather is awesome. This will be my 10th year in a row going there. Oh and yes Scottsdale was a great town to catch a game.