I was seeing as high as +105 earlier in the day. It looks like there was a sharp 10 point move at a lot of books about 25-30 minutes before game time (I saw your play after the move but you posted it before the move). I was just a bit thrown off by that big of a move.
http://www.covers.com/sports/odds/linehistory.aspx?eventId=334549&sport=mlb
Baseball - MLB (Game) Moneyline
INTERLEAGUE
(902) Cleveland Indians +110* Jun 18/12@07:05p
Competitor: (901) Cincinnati Reds
Bovada and when i took it