DAVE MALINSKY
Yankees (RL) @ Blue Jays (RL)
PICK: Blue Jays (RL) 4*
We have been putting a fair amount of money into play against the Yankees in recent weeks, and will continue to do so as long as we get the kind of extreme value that the marketplace keeps creating. The major move to them this morning, which now enables us to take Toronto +1.5 in a pick’em range, is the latest example.
As we wrote prior to cashing that 4* ticket behind A. J. Burnett last night, these are not the Bronx Bombers in 2008. The offense is simply middle of the pack in the American League, and that means that breaking games open is not easy - they have to fight for whatever they can get. So let us put it into the proper perspective in terms of tonight. the Yankees are just 45-80 as -1.5 this season, including 21-38 on the road. That can not get you into a pick’em range against a hot opponent that is bringing a lot of fire to the table.
So does the Andy Pettitte vs. David Purcey matchup explain the line? Only in terms of reputations. As -1.5, the Yankees are just 10-16 behind Pettitte, and in his only outing vs. the Blue Jays he lost 4-1 here despite not having to go up against Alex Rios or Vernon Wells. Meanwhile Purcey brings a 2-3/5.93 to the pitching forms, but all that does is create confusion in the marketplace and bring us value. Here is the story -
The young left-hander is a solid prospect, and at AAA Syracuse worked to a 2.69 ERA over 117 innings, with 121 strikeouts vs. only 97 hits allowed. But twice in the early part of the season he was called up for one-off emergency starts when he was not ready, and it showed. But since being made a full member of the rotation it has been a different story - a 2-2/4.30 , with more strikeouts (20) than hits allowed (18) is an indication of what he can become, and note that those games include difficult road tests against the Texas and Detroit offenses. His last outing was a sparkler against the Tigers in which he worked six shutout innings, only allowing two this, and that means plenty of confidence entering tonight’s start.
The Blue Jays are just a game behind the Yankees in the standings now, which means a lot of them. They have played solid baseball under Cito Gaston, and their recent 6-1 run against the Yankees, Red Sox and Tigers coincides with the return of Wells to the lineup. We do not need them to win here, just be in the hunt to the final pitch, and at pick’em that call brings strong edges.