Keeping track of the records on service plays is difficult because some guys don't get posted every week. I went back and totaled up the record for several services. These are the records of just the plays that were posted in these forums for CFB.
Millionaire's Club
2-1
Fezzik
7-2
Double Dragon (who a lot of people seem to ask for, not sure why)
5-3
Fornelli
6-5
Zack Cimini
12-9
Steve Oh
2-2
Stanford Steve
12-8
Emory Hunt
2-6
Again, these are just the records of plays that were actually posted in these forums. Some services haven't been posted every week.