Pick 2 Quarterbacks....

[Defying]

Pick ONE QB Who is the Best Quarterback in the League?
( Looking for your opinion of who is the Best QB in league - not based of potential but what they have accomplished can be passed his prime but must still be in the league, )


Pick the ONE Best Potential QB. who will give you the most stats for years to Come?
( You get any QB for your team for however long their career still is, who do you pick)

 

[CHOPTALK]

Brees
Luck

 

[Defying]

Brees
Luck

you would think Brees is better player and more accomplished than Manning or Brady?
there's only 2 possible answers.....

Luck I imagine will be the runaway choice for the 2nd part of this question, but I dont agree.

 

[CHOPTALK]

More 5000 yard passing seasons then Marino, Manning, Brady, Favre, Stafford Rodgers combined.
Will retire the all-time leader in passing yards in NFL history baring injury.

I WOULD BE interested to know who you have besides luck.

 

[slapshot]

Rodgers

Dalton

 

[JakeT.]

Brady

Bridgewater

 

[MantisToboggan]

Rodgers
Rodgers

 

[JustinCruise]

Brady (that one isn't even close)
Luck

 

[neverbend]

Brady
Kapernick

 

[packer2012]

Brady

Bridgewater

Bridgewater is an interesting (?) choice. Has not yet pissed a drop and did not even play for a "REAL" NCAA football program? Must be totally a gut call. Good luck.

Brady
Kapernick

Noticed a few people have Brady. I have always respected Brady. But.... have you really looked at his outcomes the last few seasons?

And Kapy? Are you shitting me? I really like everything else about the 49ers. Kap is really kind of a puck and stands to ruin all the rest of the potential they have. Had he not been coached and led by Harbaugh...... He would probably be a total, absolute, weapons grade shitheel like Manzeil promises to be.



Clearly Manning.

And reluctantly, Luck.

Easy answers!

 

[JustinCruise]

Bridgewater is an interesting (?) choice. Has not yet pissed a drop and did not even play for a "REAL" NCAA football program? Must be totally a gut call. Good luck.






Noticed a few people have Brady. I have always respected Brady. But.... have you really looked at his outcomes the last few seasons?

And Kapy? Are you shitting me? I really like everything else about the 49ers. Kap is really kind of a puck and stands to ruin all the rest of the potential they have. Had he not been coached and led by Harbaugh...... He would probably be a total, absolute, weapons grade shitheel like Manzeil promises to be.



Clearly Manning.

And reluctantly, Luck.

Clearly Manning? You talk about results with Brady. How about the lack of playoff results for manning? cmon now

 

[packer2012]

I'm talking more about personal (seasonal) stats. And Brady has not won anything meaningful in the playoffs for what length of time?

 

[Defying]

Manning - that part is easy for me. There's enough Manning v Brady debates on here. So reason to dwell. But it's impossible to take anyone other than Manning or Brady for the first part of this question


2nd part of it is very tough.... I just dont love Luck. I think he'll be a safe Top 10 QB every year, but I dont think he'll be elite super star.
I think Cam is the safest choice... But I really am love what I see from Ryan Tannehill. I'm talking his individual skill set, NOT picking him in fantasy because his OL is so questionable.... But skills set wise, in the right setting I think Tannehill could be a super star. So I take him... Robert Griffin III would be my 3rd choice.

 

[packer2012]

Manning - that part is easy for me. There's enough Manning v Brady debates on here. So reason to dwell. But it's impossible to take anyone other than Manning or Brady for the first part of this question


2nd part of it is very tough.... I just dont love Luck. I think he'll be a safe Top 10 QB every year, but I dont think he'll be elite super star.
I think Cam is the safest choice... But I really am love what I see from Ryan Tannehill. I'm talking his individual skill set, NOT picking him in fantasy because his OL is so questionable.... But skills set wise, in the right setting I think Tannehill could be a super star. So I take him... Robert Griffin III would be my 3rd choice.

I like your post, Man. Notice I said 'reluctantly" on Luck. I sort of feel like you do. I feel very strongly that anyone who picks Bridgewater or Kap might be stoned or drunk. some young buck potatoe-head will come on here in a minute and pick Manzeil. What a joke that would be. Cam has already far surpassed what I expected from him. I am NOT a big fan of RG III. I think they are already making too many excuses for him.

 

[Defying]

I like your post, Man. Notice I said 'reluctantly" on Luck. I sort of feel like you do. I feel very strongly that anyone who picks Bridgewater or Kap might be stoned or drunk. some young buck potatoe-head will come on here in a minute and pick Manzeil. What a joke that would be. Cam has already far surpassed what I expected from him. I am NOT a big fan of RG III. I think they are already making too many excuses for him.

I think his knee has kept RGIII from doing what he does. I would really love what he can do in the passing game (least what I saw at Baylor and in year 1 with the redskins.) Last year he missed way to many easy throws, but I think he could be one of the best passers in the game if he develops.

Same with Cam, Cam's deep ball is special. It's very Aaron Rodgers like, who IMO is the best deepball passer the game has ever seen. But Cam misses a lot of easy passes (like RGIII) Cam has a hell of a arm, and overthrows often. He needs to fix that, complete more of these shorter routes.

 

[JakeT.]

Bridgewater is an interesting (?) choice. Has not yet pissed a drop and did not even play for a "REAL" NCAA football program? Must be totally a gut call. Good luck.






Noticed a few people have Brady. I have always respected Brady. But.... have you really looked at his outcomes the last few seasons?

And Kapy? Are you shitting me? I really like everything else about the 49ers. Kap is really kind of a puck and stands to ruin all the rest of the potential they have. Had he not been coached and led by Harbaugh...... He would probably be a total, absolute, weapons grade shitheel like Manzeil promises to be.



Clearly Manning.

And reluctantly, Luck.

Easy answers!

I think Bridgewater was far and away the best QB in the draft. Maybe the best over the last few years. Love his touch.

 

[packer2012]

Stick to my guns on Bridgewater. "Has not yet pissed a drop and did not even play for a "REAL" NCAA football program!"

May not have been a top prospect in the whole draft. I wonder if Blake Bortels might turn out to be the best of the bunch?

 

[packer2012]

Look back at who Louisville played last fall. See if you feel real warm and fuzzy about "The Bridge" after you get a load of that competition.

 

[packer2012]

One problem could be...... Bortels' girlfriend is really "built for entertainment" (suspect enhancements). Seems sad for a young lady her age. Can he keep his mind on football? We will see.

 

[JakeT.]

Look back at who Louisville played last fall. See if you feel real warm and fuzzy about "The Bridge" after you get a load of that competition.

True but he was a stud the year before against Florida as well. Guy can put the ball where only his receivers can get it. Haven't seen such a quality passer in quite a while. We'll see how he pans out but it sounds like he's impressing in camp in Minnesota already.