Sean.......
My point (if I actually HAVE a point) isn't whether or not they have a right to ask for the I.D.
I've been a customer there for 7 years....and have given them a pretty fair amount of play in those years.....but even if I were a brand new customer, there is a right way & a wrong way to treat a customer.....especially when there is competition providing the same service....sometimes in a bigger & better way.
Really...when you get down to it, Olympic really doesn't have any outstanding features. And in fact during baseball season, they are pretty much the WORST book of the majors because of the 20 cent lines.
For me......it was really a loyalty issue that had kept me coming back to them every fall. Spiro was one the the first books that we could really trust to pay quickly and with no bs. He did that for years. So even with no bonuses, no free half point, no reduced vig, no rebates, no Rx contests, I have always kept Olympic high on my list from September through the end of NBA season.
I agree with you that I'd rather send in my ID than wait 5 days for a payout.....but these days those are not the only two choices.
By not informing the players of this rule proactively....and I don't mean having something posted a couple of links deep into the cashier section.....they have essentially neutralized the loyalty factor.....and without the loyalty factor, they are just another book to me.
The correct way to handle it would have been for them to have the notice posted clearly in the DEPOSITS section so that people posting up know the rules by which they are playing. Absent that, they should have sent out an e-mail notification. And failing both of those, they should have processed my withdrawal THIS time while informing me of the rules for future reference.
This not an honesty issue as I have said. It is simply bad form on a customer service level and does not inspire loyalty. Quite the opposite. The other thing I haven't mentioned is that when I called them they were....well....I won't say they were rude, but they certainly fell far short of acting like they cared the least bit about my business. Unapologetic best describes it.
No problem. I've been paid the bulk of what was posted up there (I left enough in there for one last play)....and I have already transferred the funds to other books who (so far) seem to value their clients to a greater degree.