Need input on Jeter's catch last night...

[sherman]

Arguing with a friend...I say it was a great play by Jeter, he says bad play as Cano was going to catch the ball...thoughts?

 

[MrTeaser]

To say that is not a great play is totally nuts. He made an outstanding play. What??? did Cano call him off...lol I don't think so.

 

[Jarbo]

He is The Captain - GTF out of his way. Just a typical Jeter play. One 95% of MLB players could not and would not make.

 

[sherman]

that's what I said....I just asked another guy who is a Yankees fan and he also said he should have let Cano catch it...I don't get it...

 

[RobFunk]

The catch in question is on the MLB.com home page, for those who didnt see it.


It was an awesome catch, it's got nothing on Ichiro's though.

Personally I think he just wanted to hump Cano

 

[ZZZSpeedster]

Manny would have made the play with much less dramatics

 

[BowlMeOne]

Horrible horrible play




I had Detroit

 

[sherman]

He asked me to post "if it were the other way around" would Cano be getting chit for doing that to Jeter?

 

[RobFunk]

Horrible horrible play

I had Detroit

LOL..

 

[MrTeaser]

He asked me to post "if it were the other way around" would Cano be getting chit for doing that to Jeter?

No he wouldn't. It would have been a great catch.

 

[coconutman]

Jeter is the man. When you know you can make that catch you go for it. He is the leader of that team and that's what he does. Btw Yanks are what? like .5 games back behind Boston. Pfft.

 

[DrunkenHorseplayer]

Jeter's the most overrated player in baseball; give me Rodriguez any day.

 

[Rainbow]

Jeter's the most overrated player in baseball; give me Rodriguez any day.[/QUOTe
:lolBIG:

 

[Tulsa]

Jeter's the most overrated player in baseball; give me Rodriguez any day.

You're joking, right? right? tulsa

 

[sherman]

i agree Jeter is VERY over rated, but that doesnt stop that from being a GREAT catch!