Well, I think he means there is no such person named “Jack Winningham.” Just a made up name, douchy website. You are probably “Jack.” So, is it a gift? Even though a some sports handicappers are more salesman than handicapper, and a few might be clowns, at least you can call them up and speak with them.
From my experience, NONE of them are using their real names, and they are all made up names. I'm not sure why that's important. The info should be. If you think you're calling and speaking to Brandon Lang or Al DeMarco, or some of those other people, go ahead. Sometimes you might actually get them, but in all likelihood your talking with a salesperson who's more than happy to take your cash. Although I did actually speak with John Patrick a few times. I knew it was him because I've met him and recognized his voice - and he went on and on for about 25 minutes. But it was interesting.
