Manny or AROD?

[wilheim]

Who is better?



wil.

 

[Mr.Smith]

Are you on crack?









Loser

 

[LENBO]

You can argue who is better offensively, but add defense and speed and it's no contest. A Rod easily.

 

[jjgold]

Manny way more clutch

A-Rod =loser

 

[Fishhead]

Manny ANY day of the week!

 

[WHALE]

I love the professional insight from jj about A-Rod...
How much did you loose on the Yanks???

 

[miked429]

manny cant carry arod's jock and i hate the focking yankees.

 

[MadCapper]

manny cant carry arod's jock and i hate the focking yankees.

Arod may finish his career with the Most HR's ever.

He didnt have a greta year in 04 but this guy is a SS/3B and if he played SS his whole career he would easily have the most HR ever by a SS. It would surpise me if he finishes his career with 3000 hits, 750 HR's and 1800 RBI's.

He is 29 and he has 381 HR, 1096 RBI, 1707 HITS.

10 more years?

 

[Fishhead]

Manny Is 3x The Clutch Hitter That Arod Is!

Manny Is Also 3x The Clubhouse Presence That Arod Is!

That Is Why Manny Is A Winner, Arod Is A Loser!

EVERY GM IN THE GAME REALIZES THAT NOW..........EXCEPT CASHMAN MAYBE. :biglaugh:

 

[TONYMONTANA]

Let me start by saying I am a hugh SOX fan 6-6 280.
The fact is A-ROD is a better all around player, but Manny is a better hitter and clubhouse guy. Everyone loves Manny and A-rod is considered a selfish team killer.
It's my opinion that he is sitting back waiting for his chance to take over the SS postion from Jeter and I think Jeter feels the same way. As Jeter said this is not the same team. ''We are not the Yankees of the past'' Directed at the new selfish players! I'm relieved that the deal fell through with SOX! NOW.

I'LL TAKE MANNY AND HIS GOOFY WAYS OVER THE TEAM KILLER A-ROD!:blueguy:

 

[Fishhead]

Let me make this simple.

The RED SOX as a TEAM have admitted they are a band of IDIOTS.

AROD would never stand for that!

Continue to enjoy the AROD curse in the bronx Yankee fans................you paid good money for it.

 

[blueedwards]

my sister can play left field better than manny ramirez.

 

[Fishhead]

my sister can play left field better than manny ramirez.

So?

Whats your point?

Manny can make 5 errors a game, and I would take him over AROD.

Like I said, hope the Yankee fans continue to enjoy him in the BRONX.............they paid good money for him and enjoyment is all he will be bringing.

No hardware

 

[Fishhead]

For the same money, any GM worth their salt would take Manny over AROD.

If not, they need a new hobby.

 

[Journeyman]

Manny showed alot of class this season, sucking it up after hearing he was put on waivers, nealry traded in a package deal with another superstar for one player...


Ramirez arguably the best righthanded hitter since Willie Mays and Hank Aaron being packaged in a 2 for 1, while still in his prime???


And did he sulk?

No, he just went out and had a better year than A-Rod , the best barometer is how a player is respected by his teammates, not the media ...

I'm sure Boston is happy as Texas is happy that it worked out this way.

next question

 

[MadCapper]

I dont know if Texas is happy. Soriano is horrible. That guy has totally fallen from his awesome 2002.

 

[Journeyman]

Texas had its best year since before they signed A-Rod, they don't have to pay him his ridiculous contract anymore...I don't even think they care about what they got out of it...

250 million other reasons is probably enough.

 

[Mr.Smith]

I would rather have Jeter than A Rod any day. Jeter is a winner

 

[Fishhead]

Curt Schilling Is A Bigtime Winner!

 

[RobFunk]

http://www.nike.com/usa/justdoit/v2/index.jhtml

tear jerker commercial from nike for red sox fans