Manning MVP But McNabb The Real Player

[jjgold]

Peyton could not shine McNabb's shoes not even in the same league

 

[AK]

wrong
Tom Brady in his own league until beatin in playoffs

 

[Hitman26]

Sharp post Coacher. Do you make Phili a favorite now to win it all?




Hitman

 

[RobFunk]

very true

mcnabb is like a fullback with sharp intellect and an amazing arm

 

[Ego74]

McNabb can now be considered an elite QB. A lot of folks considered him one before, but now it's solidified. It's gonna be a McNabb lovefest on ESPN for the next 2 weeks

 

[MrTeaser]

McNabb is the finished product of a QB they were hoping for...a good passer and a good runner but only runs when he needs to.

 

[RobFunk]

and playoff wise did it without owens

he really proved something here

 

[jjgold]

Pats -3

 

[bucsfan67]

Peyton could not shine McNabb's shoes not even in the same league

Might be the stupidest post i have ever seen you make coach...

Just because Indy doesnt have a good defense does not make Peyton Manning a bad coach.....

And if you are gonna tell me losing to the pats makes him a bad qb, then what does losing 3 years in a row in the nfc championship game make McNabb?...2 of those at home.....

McNabb just finally got over his playoff curse, and won a big game..

The same will happen for Peyton as well....

But to say he couldnt even shine McNabb's shoes is ridiculous...

 

[Seymour]

Manning is the best QB, followed by McNabb followed by Brady - if you want to say Brady is the best I will accept that because he has the rings to prove it - he happens to all play on the most balanced team - I consider Vick one of the bottom 5 QB's in the league - by next year every team will stack the line and NOT blitz - just get up there - creep in on him - and hold your lanes - there is no where to go - unlike McNabb when Vick scrambles he ends up running every time - when Donnie does it he has broken down the secondary and passes it - McNabb also does not throw picks and this dates back to his days at Cuse - he will low throw it intentionally and then the announcers will call him erratic.

 

[jjgold]

Manning does not have any mental toughness, put him on Eagles and they go 9-7

Manning has been exposed

 

[AK]

Manning has been exposed

:lol:

 

[RobFunk]

Manning is the best QB, followed by McNabb followed by Brady - if you want to say Brady is the best I will accept that because he has the rings to prove it - he happens to all play on the most balanced team - I consider Vick one of the bottom 5 QB's in the league - by next year every team will stack the line and NOT blitz - just get up there - creep in on him - and hold your lanes - there is no where to go - unlike McNabb when Vick scrambles he ends up running every time - when Donnie does it he has broken down the secondary and passes it - McNabb also does not throw picks and this dates back to his days at Cuse - he will low throw it intentionally and then the announcers will call him erratic.

yeah. what is wrong with all you people