Right Fair Warning, but they went 10-6 in the Big 10 while Iowa went 7-9. The Selection Committee allegedly takes conference records into consideration. Indiana shouldn't be in, IMO, but the subjective nature of this process leads to these kind of debates.
I heard Andy Katz say the other day that selection committee member told him that they weren't putting a lot of weight into the RPI, so now I wonder what the heck criteria they are using.