Favre had much better defenses than Rodgers. Not even a question.
In the 90s, yes. Early 2000's no way bro.
Name 3 players favre had on defense from 2000-2009 that were really good....besides sharper. Their corners were alright. I was biased at the time so I liked them, but they weren't great. Gilbert brown? Aaron kampman? These guys weren't bad but none of them really good. Gilbert brown was just a fat ass who clogged up the middle. Couldn't do shit besides that.
And yes in the favre/rodger eras....2010 packer defense was easily the most talented and skilled.
Favre was running off of 3 MVP awards in a row from 95-98. Rodgers really took off in the 2010 playoffs.
Defense doesn't win you three mvp awards in a row. It was his team by then. But I will say packers defense was good 94-98 when he did win those.
Favre had 8 defenses finish in the top 10 in DVOA Defense (including 2001, 2002, 2003). Rodgers has had 4.
Yeah, a lot of Packer fans fall in love with players and can't see when they are done. But Favre is a prime example. If Rodgers had the teams around him that Favre had, the Packers would have had two more Super Bowl titles. Favre threw away two titles. Rodgers has never had the defenses Favre had. Favre was great entertainment, but his drama should have been stopped sooner. And when Thompson finally said enough, the majority of Packer fans reacted by booing Rodgers. Of course, now he is the darling. Cheddar is just a typical Packers fan. I am a season ticket holder, and applaud Jordy Nelson for what he did, but know he is done.
He hasn't just had one knee surgery you dumbass. Argue for the sake of arguing why dont you. Obviously am talking about NOW. We live in the now. I don't give a fuck what he did in 2014 after the first time. It's 2018 now. And after his most recent knee injury, he has lost plenty. Including his breakaway speed. He's strictly a possession receiver now. If he wasn't, they wouldn't have released him. Do you think I like agreeing with justin lose? Don't speak to me.