Big East automatic bid to BCS is a joke. But I think I have a solution:
What needs to happen is that the Big East is dropped as a BCS conference. But their automatic bid goes to the mid-major school that has the highest BCS ranking, Big East included. This year, Utah would get that automatic bid. Big East would still have a decent chance of making a BCS bid in upcoming years, but only if they had a top team deserving. This would quiet the controversy every year about the mid majors always being left out, as one would make it every year. This would make for some very interesting bowl games year in and year out, as the top mid-major every year would be gunning for a top program from a BCS conference.
I think this is the best solution, but would like to hear some opinions on it.