Is Peyton Manning Done after this Season ??

[Betallsports 0]

Imho, 100%

 

[bigsmooth 0]

I agree.

 

[Willie99 1,630]

he better be, otherwise he's just being stubborn

 

[Betallsports 0]

he better be, otherwise he's just being stubborn

Well we all remember what Favre did

 

[Willie99 1,630]

I know, case in point

and I think Farve still had some sort of arm, Peyton has none

and as bad as Farve was in some years, I don't think he was ever the worst rated QB in the league

 

[Vlad the Impaler 0]

First, let's watch what we say about Peyton.

Secondly, yes he should retire. You can tell by the look in his eyes. Sure they are 6-0 but he doesn't have it and he knows it . He won't pull a Favre though. The mental is there but the physical is 3 steps behind. He redefined the game.

 

[Willie99 1,630]

First, let's watch what we say about Peyton.

Secondly, yes he should retire. You can tell by the look in his eyes. Sure they are 6-0 but he doesn't have it and he knows it . He won't pull a Favre though. The mental is there but the physical is 3 steps behind. He redefined the game.

so you agree with us, great

 

[Willie99 1,630]

and he did redefine the game, he's the reason you see so much defensive holding calls nowadays

they changed the rules just to appease the Peyton Manning Colts






whoop whoop whoop, oh no I didn't

 

[Vlad the Impaler 0]

Like Bill hasn't cheated those rules to death

 

[Vlad the Impaler 0]

It's more probable than not

 

[Vlad the Impaler 0]

Does Willie consider Manning one of the all time greats?

 

[Stax 0]

I hope so....I'm tired of hearing about him and tired of his dumbass commercials.

 

[Stax 0]

Brady>Peyton

 

[Redagger029 0]

He's hanging on by a thread. Let it go Peyton. Enjoy your retirement.

 

[VIEJODINOSAUR 3,010]

And take his brother with him....

 

[Vlad the Impaler 0]

Brady>Peyton

Good one

 

[Soriano12 1,960]

Hopefully so and I think he will. Favre even at the end was still a decent QB. Manning right now is done: Yes he was great in his prime for many many years, but if he wasn't Peyton Manning (or maybe a rookie picked at #1 or #2), he probably would already have been benched already.
To me it's less mind boggling, that he has almost no arm left, but that despite his physical limitations and the way his defense has carried this team, he has made some terrible decisions trying to force throws into double coverage or hanging jumpballs up there that get picked off. You would think with his football IQ he would understand his current limitations better than anybody else and know how to work around them. Instead he is too stubborn(?) to adapt and turns the ball over and over again, not even counting the times, where Thomas & Sanders bail him out with great plays at the receiving end. Most of their games so far probably still wouldn't have been close, if he just had managed the game by making sure to not turn over the ball and let his defense and special teams win games for them.

 

[Betallsports 0]

I hope so....I'm tired of hearing about him and tired of his dumbass commercials.

We will probably see More Commercials when he retires

 

[Willie99 1,630]

Does Willie consider Manning one of the all time greats?

yes









maybe 2nd best

 

[Greenbacks 3,255]

I believe he will hang it up at the end of the season......Lucky for him his team is solid on the defensive side of the ball....As bad as he`s been this defense might be able to make some noise in the playoffs....We`ll see.