Are you looking at 1 game? or the season? Confused here? He is 42 and eats a ton of innings.. What he does for that pitching staff can not be measured.. Big freaking deal.. he is their #4 or #5 starter.
Who cares what the moneyline was? red Sox at home after a loss vs Pelfrey.. your never going to get value? And didn't he go deep into the game and they won the game.
I have a feeling you will not find 1 person on this Forum.. that will call a 42 yr old pitcher who gets the teams 10-12 wins, cost them a minimal 4 million a year ( price for a avg utility man and eats over 180 innings a year, saves the bull pen etc...... Overated? )