if you owned an NFL Franchise-

Search

New member
Joined
Sep 11, 2005
Messages
2,944
Tokens
Its not like he had Aaron Rodgers as his qb those 2 years, the guy can coach. I think Rexs main problem is that hes a coach and doesnt do the front office politics very well.
 

Member
Handicapper
Joined
Oct 31, 2004
Messages
44,321
Tokens
If you owned an NFL team mike I would hope your team played in the NFC South and not named the Saints. Haha jk

As for the Ryan brothers.

I like Rob Ryan and don't put any of the blame for what is happening to the Saints on him.

When you are starting a safety that was on another teams practice squad 2 weeks before there is only so much you can do.

The Saints have about 70 million dollars worth of safeties on IR right now.
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
I honestly think that both of these guys get exposed after a couple of years no matter where they are. Every team faces injury and adversity every year.

I think we will see in a few years when we run this Merry-Go-Round again....
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
Rex has been a coach or DC in 2 places. HC w/ NYJ, DC w/ B-more

The Ravens lost in the AFCCG in his 4th year as DC of their team to a team with far superior QB play. That might be stretching "a few years" out
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
Rex has been a coach or DC in 2 places. HC w/ NYJ, DC w/ B-more

The Ravens lost in the AFCCG in his 4th year as DC of their team to a team with far superior QB play. That might be stretching "a few years" out
"Far superior QB play?"....are you implying that he took a mediocre defense and put them at the top for almost half a decade?





OK, you're right, he should be in Canton.....
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
No I'm saying in 2008 Ben Roethlisberger was a far better QB than a rookie Joe Flacco. Hence why the Steelers pretty much owned that rivalry vs the Ravens.

And no I never implied that. You said after a few years his stuff doesn't work anymore or something, almost making the superbowl in your 4th year probably would indicate there isn't an expiration date on his coaching methods.
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
Rex has been a coach or DC in 2 places. HC w/ NYJ, DC w/ B-more

The Ravens lost in the AFCCG in his 4th year as DC of their team to a team with far superior QB play. That might be stretching "a few years" out
Let's see who Sexy Rexy had to work with....
Ray Lewis
Bart Scott
Ed Reed
Terrell Suggs
Jarret Johnson
Trevor Price
Somari Rolles

Sounds like the General Manager deserves just a small bit of credit there...
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
If you had top ranked defenses that competed for the superbowl birth on 4 different occasions with mediocre to abysmal QB play every single time

I dunno, maybe you know some shit about coaching defense.
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
No I'm saying in 2008 Ben Roethlisberger was a far better QB than a rookie Joe Flacco. Hence why the Steelers pretty much owned that rivalry vs the Ravens.

And no I never implied that. You said after a few years his stuff doesn't work anymore or something, almost making the superbowl in your 4th year probably would indicate there isn't an expiration date on his coaching methods.
Are you trying to imply that if he had the same caliber of players that other DC's had that year he would have performed above average?.....not buying it.

You took a one year snapshot out of a career where he caught lightning in a bottle because his owner and general manager put together one of the best group of defensive players ever assembled to play for him.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
What one year snapshot? He has had many years coaching good defenses with two different teams.

He caught lightning in a bottle one year yet the next 2 years he had success with an entirely different team? You are suspending a lot of disbelief with that one.

Pretty much all of his success has come on teams with limited QB stability and that is the biggest edge/correlation to team success you can have in the NFL.
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
If you had top ranked defenses that competed for the superbowl birth on 4 different occasions with mediocre to abysmal QB play every single time

I dunno, maybe you know some shit about coaching defense.
Do you realize that 2 of his 4 years as DC with Baltimore he had a losing record? As a matter of fact it was terrible.

You want to take that one year where he was assembled an All-Star team and just because it was in his 4th year use that as the bell weather of his coaching career?

Even you could have had excellent Defensive numbers with that group of guys.
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
What one year snapshot? He has had many years coaching good defenses with two different teams.

He caught lightning in a bottle one year yet the next 2 years he had success with an entirely different team? You are suspending a lot of disbelief with that one.

Pretty much all of his success has come on teams with limited QB stability and that is the biggest edge/correlation to team success you can have in the NFL.
You are jumping from DC to HC, then back......as a DC with Baltimore he had 2 winning seasons and 2 losing seasons in his 4 years there. He did this with one of the best group of talent ever assembled on one side of the ball. He only went 2-2.

We can talk about the JETS if you want too but let's not try to marry and mix the two together to suit a side to an arguement.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
Maintaining defense is much harder than maintaining offense in the NFL. Pretty much why all teams try to build around offense.

Just way too many variables to sustain top tier defense on a regular basis. They were terrible offensively and decimated with injuries those 2 years.

You said after a few years his stuff doesn't work or something based on a sample size of 1 with a Jets team that was highly deficient offensively. I'm not even sure what doesn't work ater a few years? The schemes? the players stop buying in? Sounds like an ESPN type narrative thing with no factual basis to me.
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
If you had top ranked defenses that competed for the superbowl birth on 4 different occasions with mediocre to abysmal QB play every single time

I dunno, maybe you know some shit about coaching defense.
Which years are you talking about?
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
'06, '08, '09, '10

3 AFCCG, 1 2nd rd loss...All with terrible QB play

The next time someone mans a defense and accomplishes that in a 5 year period, bump this thread and let me know. Considering the way the game is going it is probably never going to happen again.
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
There is just no available information that says the man can't coach defense.

If there was, I'd say he couldn't coach defense but I'm just too biased towards the truth. Gift and a curse....
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
Maintaining defense is much harder than maintaining offense in the NFL. Pretty much why all teams try to build around offense.

Just way too many variables to sustain top tier defense on a regular basis. They were terrible offensively and decimated with injuries those 2 years.

You said after a few years his stuff doesn't work or something based on a sample size of 1 with a Jets team that was highly deficient offensively. I'm not even sure what doesn't work ater a few years? The schemes? the players stop buying in? Sounds like an ESPN type narrative thing with no factual basis to me.
No factual basis?

How about his record?

You brought up his history with Baltimore as a DC, that's the only record that I have referenced. Now you are talking about a sample size with the Jets?

Just so you are aware, he was a DC with Baltimore for 3 years, than , DC/assistant HC with them for a 4th year before going to the JETS. He has only been HC over there (starting in 2009 till present).
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
So the Ravens were successful with him after a few years. The Jets haven't been as successful (although they did go 8-8 last year which is pretty solid for a team with about 4 wins worth of talent)

So your sample size for your "he wears thin after a few years" narrative is 1.
 

Scottcarter was caught making out with Caitlin Jen
Joined
Feb 2, 2008
Messages
12,907
Tokens
'06, '08, '09, '10

3 AFCCG, 1 2nd rd loss...All with terrible QB play

The next time someone mans a defense and accomplishes that in a 5 year period, bump this thread and let me know. Considering the way the game is going it is probably never going to happen again.
6,8,9 10?

You are making my point......other than his last year with Baltimore (when his defense was absolutely stacked), what has he done after being with a team for just a few years?

That is my whole point........Are you kidding me with this?
 

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
31,503
Tokens
6,8,9 10?

You are making my point......other than his last year with Baltimore (when his defense was absolutely stacked), what has he done after being with a team for just a few years?

That is my whole point........Are you kidding me with this?

He has only been with a team after a few years twice in his entire career. The Jets, a team with no QB and no offense have struggled the last few years, as do most teams with no QB over a large sample in the NFL. Why would he be immune to that?

You are the one pushing the "few years" narrative that I've never even heard anyone say before. What do you think in his skillset doesn't work after a few years that works the first few years? The schemes? Motivational factors?

What is the reason his ability to coach defenses regresses as time goes on in your opinion? I really don't view coaches or players like that, just pretty much on what I think their ability is, so obviously I have no clue.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,110,218
Messages
13,467,352
Members
99,526
Latest member
toyatang41
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com